Skip to content

docs(roadmap): close cycle 9 and record cycle 10 decision #72

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Merged
SYMBaiEX merged 1 commit into from
Oct 5, 2026
Merged

docs(roadmap): close cycle 9 and record cycle 10 decision #72

Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
1 commit
Select commit
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension
Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
68 changes: 57 additions & 11 deletions docs/roadmap/ai-gaming-opportunities.md
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
# OpenController AI and Gaming Opportunity Goal

**Status:** Cycle 1 merged in PRs #1–#4. Cycle 2 issues #8 and #9 merged in PRs #12 and #13; #10 remains deferred. Cycle 3 issue #14 merged in PR #19; #15 remains deferred. Cycle 4 issue #22 merged in PR #25; gate #23 closed in PR #30. Cycle 5 issue #27 merged in PR #32; gate #29 closed in PR #36 at `f44fe793ea4fef069c2a187084fcaa536848b336`. Cycle 6 issue #20 merged in PR #38 at `f20aab9ea80be7e01b5337c9000b6322f4a8bb5d`; gate #35 and milestone 5 closed in PR #43. Cycle 7 gate #37 closed in PR #48; all six selected issues (#39–#42, #45, #47) are implemented and merged in PRs #49–#54, and milestone 6 is closed. #44 and #46 remain deferred. Whole-match regression baselines and Reddit/accessibility coverage remain open gaps. Cycle 8 gate #57 closed in PR #63; selected issues #58, #59, and #61 merged in PRs #66, #64, and #65. Cycle 9 gate #67 ranks repository findings #34 and #33 and is closed by the Cycle 8 closeout/decision PR before their implementation starts. GitHub Project V2 creation is blocked by the integration's missing Projects write access; repository milestones, labels, issue dependencies, and recurring goal issue #55 track the DAG.
**Status:** Cycle 1 merged in PRs #1–#4. Cycle 2 issues #8 and #9 merged in PRs #12 and #13; #10 remains deferred. Cycle 3 issue #14 merged in PR #19; #15 remains deferred. Cycle 4 issue #22 merged in PR #25; gate #23 closed in PR #30. Cycle 5 issue #27 merged in PR #32; gate #29 closed in PR #36 at `f44fe793ea4fef069c2a187084fcaa536848b336`. Cycle 6 issue #20 merged in PR #38 at `f20aab9ea80be7e01b5337c9000b6322f4a8bb5d`; gate #35 and milestone 5 closed in PR #43. Cycle 7 gate #37 closed in PR #48; all six selected issues (#39–#42, #45, #47) are implemented and merged in PRs #49–#54, and milestone 6 is closed. #44 and #46 remain deferred. Whole-match regression baselines and Reddit/accessibility coverage remain open gaps. Cycle 8 gate #57 closed in PR #63; selected issues #58, #59, and #61 merged in PRs #66, #64, and #65. Cycle 9 gate #67 ranks repository findings #34 and #33 and was closed by Cycle 8 closeout/decision PR #68. Both implementation PRs #69 and #70 are merged; milestone 8 is closed. Cycle 10 gate #71 completed the AI, gaming, and accessibility sweep and repository audit; it selected no new implementation because current signals were upstream-owned, weak-fit, or already tracked. Milestone 9 closes with this decision. GitHub Project V2 creation is blocked by the integration's missing Projects write access; repository milestones, labels, issue dependencies, and recurring goal issue #55 track the DAG.

## Product goal

Expand Down Expand Up @@ -160,13 +160,15 @@ still not probed by the current native doctor, so their readiness remains

```mermaid
flowchart TD
A[Cycle 5 closeout PR #36 merged; close gate #29] --> B[Cycle 6 gate #35]
C[Selected native-test cleanup #20] --> B
B --> D[Implementation PR #38 merged]
D --> E[Cycle 6 roadmap closeout PR; close gate #35 and milestone 5]
E --> F[Cycle 7 research gate #37]
F --> G[Create and rank independent candidate issues]
G --> H[Select parallel build lanes and form implementation DAG]
A[Cycle 7 closeout PR #56; milestone 6 closed] --> B[Cycle 8 gate #57]
B --> C[Decision PR #63; select #58, #59, #61]
C --> D[Implementation PRs #64, #65, #66]
D --> E[Cycle 8 closeout / Cycle 9 decision PR #68]
E --> F[Cycle 9 parallel PRs #69 and #70]
F --> G[Cycle 9 closeout; milestone 8 closed]
G --> H[Cycle 10 gate #71; public research and repository audit]
H --> I[No new SDK-owned candidate; close milestone 9]
I --> J[Continue the recurring research gate]
```

The DAG repeats research, repository audit, bounded selection, implementation,
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -571,12 +573,56 @@ The selected issues have disjoint primary files. Build them in separate worktree
- [x] Rank repository findings #34 and #33 and defer unsupported/out-of-scope ideas.
- [x] Put #33 and #34 in milestone 8 with candidate labels and native dependencies from #67.
- [x] Wait for Cycle 8 issue #58 and the closeout/decision PR before releasing implementation.
- [ ] Implement and independently review #34 and #33 on exact PR heads.
- [ ] Merge both lanes with relevant checks and record commits/results.
- [ ] Close milestone 8 and start the next evidence sweep.
- [x] Implement and independently review #34 and #33 on exact PR heads.
- [x] Merge both lanes with relevant checks and record commits/results.
- [x] Close milestone 8 and start the next evidence sweep.

The recurring research/build/review/merge checklist remains in [#55](https://github.com/SYMBaiEX/OpenController/issues/55). Cycle 9 is not a claim that every forum or pain point was covered; its source limits remain explicit in #67.

## Cycle 9 implementation closeout (2026-10-05)

Both selected repository-correctness issues are merged. Milestone 8 closed with zero open issues. Each final code head passed GitHub's `test` check and received independent internal gpt-6-luna review with no blockers.

| Issue | PR and merge commit | Result and validation |
| --- | --- | --- |
| [#33](https://github.com/SYMBaiEX/OpenController/issues/33) | [#69](https://github.com/SYMBaiEX/OpenController/pull/69), `42d7a3aac764ba949fe4083eaf24eff3ebadf986` | Both native bridge adapters now derive touchpad, motion, and profile HID claims from the same output options as the serializer. Default and fully suppressed modes are tested for both adapters; accepted commands remain advertised. Adapter docs distinguish SDK serialization from downstream support. Core tests (82/82), workspace build (10 tasks), typecheck, targeted Biome, diff check, GitHub CI, and independent review passed. CodeRabbit status passed with a rate-limit note. |
| [#34](https://github.com/SYMBaiEX/OpenController/issues/34) | [#70](https://github.com/SYMBaiEX/OpenController/pull/70), `c4791ddab2a103cc30df58a10904f8fac4cd3052` | Rejects negative durations before commands enter the runtime queue, including trigger and nested sequence/action-map commands. Zero-duration persistent input and positive trigger release remain valid. Focused public API tests (2 tests, 18 assertions), core tests (82/82), core typecheck/build, changed-file Biome, GitHub CI, and exact-head review passed. The branch was rebased after #69. CodeRabbit review remained pending at merge; the independent Luna review found no blocker. |

The Cycle 9 selection was based on verified repository behavior, not an externally demonstrated OpenController incident. The public reports in gate #67 mostly concern upstream drivers, game engines, remote-play clients, adaptive-controller firmware, or model-provider limits. No first-party telemetry exists and Reddit mirrors were blocked; source coverage is not exhaustive.

Cycle 9 gate #67 closed in PR #68 at `aa57f176d8bfada5e51d8ee5244fa6591f0b0ace`. Issues #33 and #34 are closed, and milestone 8 is closed. Its acceptance checklist is complete:

- [x] Gather public evidence and record its limits and fit.
- [x] Audit repository behavior and distinguish code findings from external reports.
- [x] Rank #34 and #33 and keep unsupported requests deferred.
- [x] Put both issues in milestone 8 with native gate dependencies.
- [x] Close Cycle 8 issue #58 and the Cycle 8 closeout before releasing implementation.
- [x] Implement and independently review both exact PR heads.
- [x] Merge both PRs and close milestone 8 with zero open issues.

## Cycle 10 research gate (#71)

Three gpt-6-luna research lanes covered AI-agent/game control, gaming/platform reports, and accessibility/adaptive input. A separate Luna repository audit checked the results against the SDK boundary and existing issues. The dated source log, workarounds, evidence confidence, fit assessment, and coverage gaps are recorded in [gate #71](https://github.com/SYMBaiEX/OpenController/issues/71).

The sweep found detailed but low-fit desktop Computer Use reports such as [Codex #44074](https://github.com/openai/codex/issues/44074), upstream Proton/Godot/SDL/Sunshine driver or consumer reports, and Steam Controller accessibility anecdotes from 2015–2023. These do not establish an uncovered OpenController defect. OpenController already supports bounded gamepad presses and cancellation (#39, #34), while controller profile documentation says its keyboard/mouse names do not emit desktop events. The one-handed Steam Controller exchange describes concurrent Steam Input devices but does not demonstrate an unmet OpenController API need.

The repository audit selected no new issue. Existing #46 (helper readiness) remains gated on an owned helper acknowledgement contract; #60 (persistent-state expiry) remains deferred because no OpenController stale-state incident was shown and timer/error ordering is nontrivial. #21, #28, and #62 still need a named host/game or supported hardware test path. The decision is a deliberate no-build result, not a claim that demand is absent: Reddit and several search/community endpoints returned 403, Steam search rate-limited, and no first-party telemetry or hardware verification is available.

The Cycle 10 decision DAG is:

```mermaid
flowchart TD
A[AI, gaming, accessibility source sweep] --> B[Repository and duplicate-issue audit]
B --> C{Uncovered SDK-owned candidate with evidence?}
C -->|No: Cycle 10| D[Record no-build decision and close milestone 9]
C -->|Yes| E[Create scoped issues and dependency DAG]
E --> F[Parallel Luna worktrees and PRs]
F --> G[Exact-head checks and independent review]
G --> H[Merge in DAG order; start next research gate]
D --> H
```

The recurring goal [#55](https://github.com/SYMBaiEX/OpenController/issues/55) carries the research/build/review/merge checklist forward. Continue the next source sweep from fresh reports; do not reopen deferred work unless its evidence or prerequisites change.
## Branch and swarm operating rules


Expand Down
Loading