Repository navigation
Description
Problem
cpp_library_map_dependency() stores each mapping in a global property keyed only by the dependency target. During package-config generation, the mapping takes precedence over the dependency version tracked for the library being exported. A nested project's mapping can therefore silently change a parent library's generated find_dependency() requirement.
With cpp-library 6.0.2, cel-std 1.0.3 maps cel::parser to cel-parser 1.0.2 CONFIG. A parent that directly requires parser 1.1.0 can consequently export a 1.0.2 minimum after adding cel-std, unless the parent repeats its own mapping. For cel-euclid, parser 1.0.2 lacks the record-registration APIs it uses.
The global storage and lookup are in cpp-library-install.cmake and the dependency generator.
Reproduction
The following configure-only reproduction simulates a tracked CPM parser 1.1.0; it uses the internal generator to inspect what a package config would contain without installing anything. Pass -DCPP_LIBRARY_ROOT=/path/to/cpp-library when configuring.
# CMakeLists.txt
cmake_minimum_required(VERSION 3.24)
project(repro LANGUAGES CXX)
include("${CPP_LIBRARY_ROOT}/cmake/cpp-library-install.cmake")
add_library(parser INTERFACE)
add_library(cel::parser ALIAS parser)
add_library(euclid INTERFACE)
target_link_libraries(euclid INTERFACE cel::parser)
set(CPM_PACKAGES cel-parser)
set(CPM_PACKAGE_cel-parser_VERSION 1.1.0)
_cpp_library_generate_dependencies(before euclid cel)
message(STATUS "before: ${before}")
add_subdirectory(child)
_cpp_library_generate_dependencies(after euclid cel)
message(STATUS "after: ${after}")# child/CMakeLists.txt
cpp_library_map_dependency("cel::parser" "cel-parser 1.0.2 CONFIG")Observed output:
before: find_dependency(cel-parser 1.1.0)
after: find_dependency(cel-parser 1.0.2 CONFIG)
Expected behavior
A library's exported dependency requirements should not be overwritten by an unrelated nested project's mapping. Provide an appropriately scoped mapping mechanism and cover nested projects in cpp-library's existing dependency-mapping tests.
stlab/cel-std#2 removes the particular 1.0.2 mapping as part of a dependency update; the global collision remains possible for other projects that need explicit mappings. Discovered while updating stlab/cel-euclid#1.
Activity