feat: VSM loop orchestration, PROV-O schema, atom matrix, graphiti integration#1
Open
ganzuul wants to merge 88 commits into
Open
feat: VSM loop orchestration, PROV-O schema, atom matrix, graphiti integration#1ganzuul wants to merge 88 commits into
ganzuul wants to merge 88 commits into
Conversation
…ibrary improvements - docs/graphiti_integration_spec.md: 11-section integration architecture spec - docs/test_plan_graphiti_integration.md: 6-level, 57-test plan - tests/graphiti_integration/: 9 test files + conftest.py (89 tests, all passing) - Level 1: Pydantic model constraints + EDGE_TYPE_MAP completeness (43 tests) - Level 2: Hypothesis property-based invariants (9 tests) - Level 3: Migration parity with existing pipeline (10 tests) - Level 4: Graphiti + FalkorDB Lite operations (10 tests) - Level 5: Cross-layer NormCode/bridge integration (4 tests) - Level 6: End-to-end bootstrap/audit/discovery (4 tests) - Resource safety: Memory/time/disk limits (4 tests) - pyproject.toml: pytest-asyncio config, test markers, graphiti deps - reasoning_library/: clusterer, compressor, embedder, mcp_server, parser, pipeline improvements + tests + __main__.py entry point - docs/ChatGPT_on_ReasoningLibrary.md + docs/arXiv-2512.10563v3/: NormCode paper source (2512.10563v3) and reasoning library schema references - session-ses_1075.md: session trace fixture for migration tests
…erCortex and NormCode This commit implements the blood-brain barrier pattern that explicitly correlates OWL two-word compositions (formal identifiers in LaserCortex's grammar algebra) with their natural language phrasing (from reasoning traces and tool calls). Changes: - docs/graphiti_integration_spec.md: - Add owl_key and nl_value fields to NormNode - Add owl_key field to CortexNode - Add OwlKeyValuePair edge type with key, value, coupling_signature, cd_step - Update EDGE_TYPE_MAP to include OWL_KEY_VALUE_PAIR - Add blood-brain barrier note explaining the separation - docs/test_plan_graphiti_integration.md: - Add 3 new unit tests (L1) for model field validation - Add 3 new invariant tests (L2) for consistency, uniqueness, presence - Add 2 new integration tests (L4) for ingestion and query - Add 1 new cross-layer test (L5) for full lift correlation - Update test counts: 57 -> 62 tests - tests/graphiti_integration/test_01_models.py: - Add TestNormNodeOwlKey (5 tests) - Add TestCortexNodeOwlKey (2 tests) - Add TestOwlKeyValuePair (5 tests) - Add OwlKeyValuePairAttrs model - tests/graphiti_integration/test_02_invariants.py: - Add TestOwlKeyValueConsistency - Add TestOwlKeyUniqueness - Add TestOwlKeyPresenceForCdStep - tests/graphiti_integration/test_01_edge_map.py: - Add OWL_KEY_VALUE_PAIR to EDGE_TYPE_MAP - Add OWL_KEY_VALUE_PAIR to ALL_EDGE_TYPES - tests/graphiti_integration/test_04_graphiti.py: - Add TestOwlKeyValuePair with ingestion and query tests - tests/graphiti_integration/test_05_cross_layer.py: - Add TestOwlKeyValueLift with full correlation test The blood-brain barrier analogy: - NormCode acts as the barrier between two domains - Formal domain (LaserCortex): OWL keys stored in owl_key fields - Natural language domain (reasoning): NL values stored in nl_value fields - OwlKeyValuePair edges explicitly correlate them This enables queries like: - Find all traces using OWL key ReserveGuard - What is the NL phrasing for MarketClosure - Show me the correlation between formal and natural language representations Co-authored-by: ganzuul <ganzuul@users.noreply.github.com>
…tegration VSM Loop Orchestration (eigenstate oracle): - infra/_cortex/_vsm_loop.py: VSM convergence loop with 7 GAPs documented in Lean (Generation.lean §12). Manages data/garbage classification of trace phrases via embedding stability thresholds. - 37 tests passing. COUPLING_TO_LOGIC corrected (non-commutative → INTUITIONISTIC per Hopf 7-Skeleton cdStep taxonomy). - infra/_graphiti_service.py: Graphiti temporal graph service for episode/claim/edge operations, persists to FalkorDB Lite. - scripts/mcp_normcode_server.py: integrates Graphiti service and vsm_loop MCP tool. Prov-O schema for Graphiti: - scripts/provo_graphiti_schema.py: parses PROV-O OWL (30 classes, 44 properties) into Graphiti module format with semantic relations. - scripts/graphiti_bootstrap.py: bootstraps PROV-O schema into the temporal graph with entity/attribute/activity mappings. Atom matrix with fail-fast resilience: - scripts/m0_bootstrap_atoms.py: extracts 428 reinforcement atoms from 758 traces across 5 sources (framenet, verbnet, manpage, prov-o, p-plan). - scripts/m1_build_atom_matrix.py: cosine activation matrix builder with per-source 95th-percentile normalization, cache invalidation on count mismatch, fail-fast on embedding errors (batches up to 758), and structured logging to data/m1_build_atom_matrix.log. Eigenstate formalization (Lean): - Generation.lean §12: ToolOutput, UngroundedNL structures; hyperstitionCost_unbounded theorem; ViableSystem (S1–S5 mapping); laserCortexSystem definition with cdStep-aware regulation. Documentation: - docs/vsm_eigenstate.md: eigenstate foundation, gap taxonomy, coupling-to-logic specification. - docs/vsm_architecture.md: 3-layer architecture (trace, atom, activation). - docs/vsm_loop_interface.md: vsm_loop MCP tool spec. - docs/reinforcement_type_discovery_plan.md: atom bootstrapping plan. Embedding utilities: - scripts/embed_lifting.py: embeds PROV-O + trace data with bge-m3 (15-20 min runtime). - scripts/analyse_provo_embedding.py: analysis of ProvO embeddings. - scripts/vsm_mine_traces.py: VSM trace mining. - scripts/phrase_lagrangian.py: phrase Lagrangian scoring. - scripts/ontology_discrimination_test.py: ontology discrimination test. Bug fixes: - infra/_cortex/_spec.py: COUPLING_TO_LOGIC corrected — "non-commutative" was mapped to TEMPORAL (cdStep 1, still commutative); now maps to INTUITIONISTIC (cdStep 2, commutativity lost).
… LaserCortex and NormCode This commit implements the OWL key-value pairing feature as specified in docs/graphiti_integration_spec.md (commit cfe0025). Changes: - Add infra/_graphiti_models.py: Shared Pydantic models for all custom entity and edge types including NormNode, CortexNode, and OwlKeyValuePair with owl_key and nl_value fields for blood-brain barrier pattern - Update infra/_graphiti_service.py: Add methods for OWL key-value pairing - add_episode_with_entities(): Support custom entity/edge types - add_owl_key_value_pair(): Convenience method with invariant validation - verify_owl_invariants(): Database-level invariant verification - Add scripts/graphiti_owl_integration.py: Demonstration script showing the blood-brain barrier pattern in action with sample OWL pairs The blood-brain barrier pattern ensures: - LaserCortex (formal layer): Uses OWL two-word compositions as keys - NormCode (reasoning layer): Uses natural language phrasing as values - NormCode maintains separation but correlation via OWL_KEY_VALUE_PAIR edges Invariants enforced: 1. NormNode.owl_key == CortexNode.owl_key == OwlKeyValuePair.key 2. NormNode.nl_value == OwlKeyValuePair.value 3. NormNode.coupling_signature == OwlKeyValuePair.coupling_signature 4. CortexNode.cd_step == OwlKeyValuePair.cd_step 5. OWL keys are unique across NormNodes 6. CortexNode with cd_step >= 1 must have non-empty owl_key All 82 existing tests pass (25 skipped requiring FalkorDB Lite). Related to commit cfe0025 which added the spec for this feature. Co-authored-by: ganzuul <ganzuul@users.noreply.github.com>
This plan document captures the design for explicitly storing and querying the learning trajectory pattern where models hone in on success through coherent error messages. Key components: - ErrorNode, SuccessNode: Track individual error and success events - ErrorSuccessRecipeNode: Compressed patterns of error→success trajectories - ErrorRoutingPolicyNode: Route errors to appropriate correction strategies - New edge types: ENCOUNTERS_ERROR, CORRECTS_TO, ACHIEVES_SUCCESS, etc. Implementation phases: 1. Data extraction from existing traces 2. Graph schema additions 3. Ingestion pipeline 4. Compression and routing 5. Query and application 6. Learning and improvement Includes: - Coherence metrics (semantic, progressive, intent) - Invariant definitions - Query patterns - Integration points with reasoning library, MCP server, VSM loop - Testing strategy - Risk assessment - Example trajectories Status: Draft (ready for refinement) Co-authored-by: ganzuul <ganzuul@users.noreply.github.com>
This document provides a comprehensive plan for deconstructing the phrase "Nothing is more meaningful than this" as a floating terminator with a degenerate mode (simultaneously idempotent and misleading). Key components: - Problem analysis: Floating terminator concept, degenerate mode with opposing trajectories (A: idempotent, B: misleading/negative info value) - OWL primitive deconstruction: Token-level decomposition, semantic primitive extraction, EML tree representation, OWL key-value pairs - Formal translation: Lean4 code for Problem, AntiCoherentPair, Superposition, EMLTree with theorems - Divergence detection: Composition space, divergence criteria, composition matrix, formal proofs - Zero-divisor construction: Definition, construction from superposition, CD 2→3 boundary proof - Decision matrix: Governing principles from existing material, decision matrix application - Implementation plan: 5 phases from primitive extraction to integration Key insights: - The phrase maps to ProblemClass.inconsistentDef (like Barber/Russell) - It straddles CD 0 (Classical) and CD 4 (Paraconsistent) - The composition Universal + Comparative + Self is divergent - It's structurally identical to the Barber Paradox - Only Free logic (meta-logic) can resolve it without creating a ZD References existing material: - Generation.lean (Superposition, AntiCoherentPair, inflate) - LogicTypes.lean (LogicType hierarchy, cdStep) - Problem.lean (ProblemClass) - FrictionLagrangian.lean (sector boundary, zero divisors) - VSM architecture (System 4/3/5 mapping) - Paradoxes and logics (inconsistentDef → Paraconsistent) Status: Active Research (ready for refinement and execution) Co-authored-by: ganzuul <ganzuul@users.noreply.github.com>
…ual short-list - Expand CLASSICAL_INDICATORS and PARACONSISTENT_INDICATORS with terms from codebase - Add KNOWN_OWL_KEYS, CD_STEP_OVERRIDES, and PARADOX_OVERRIDES for known terms - Add camel_to_natural_language() function for proper NL value conversion - Improve extraction from Lean, NCD, and Python files with better NL values - Add manual short-list of 18 most relevant paradox candidates - Generate clean Python short-list for programmatic use - Save results to data/owl_paradox_candidates.json Key candidates identified: - ReserveGuard, MarketClosure (CD 2->3 boundary) - AntiCoherentPair (explicit classical vs paraconsistent) - SelfCheckNorm, NonAssociativeBudget, SplitOctonion, SplitQuat - LogicContraction, LogicTranslation, ConcreteReactionlessShift - UngroundedNL, VeryBigBox - BarberParadox, LiarParadox, RussellsParadox, SoritesParadox - TemporalParadox, ProofParadox Co-authored-by: ganzuul <ganzuul@users.noreply.github.com>
…ndex Provides a clean Python script that returns single candidate OWL entries and their index as requested. Supports both individual candidate lookup and complete list output. Usage: python scripts/get_owl_candidates.py # All candidates python scripts/get_owl_candidates.py 3 # Specific candidate by index Includes 18 manually curated paradox candidates with: - OWL_KEY: PascalCase formal identifier - NL_VALUE: Natural language description - CD_STEP: Contraction depth step (2, 3, or 4) - REASONING: Explanation of paradox signature Co-authored-by: ganzuul <ganzuul@users.noreply.github.com>
… repository content The previous scripts were incorrectly sourcing OWL key-value pairings from repository content (blood), but the pairings should be derived from OWL primitives themselves (brain). This corrected script: - Extracts OWL primitives from LaserCortex grammar algebra (BRAIN) - Creates compositions with proper CD step assignments - Derives NL values via transformation (BLOOD) - Maintains strict separation: formal keys ≠ repository content - Identifies 10 paradox candidates that straddle CD 2→3 boundary: * ReserveGuard (Reserve=CD2 + Guard=CD3) * MarketClosure (Market=CD3 + Closure=CD2) * AntiCoherentPair (Anti=CD4 + Coherent=CD2 + Pair=CD2) * SelfCheckNorm (Self=CD3 + Check=CD2 + Norm=CD3) * NonAssociativeBudget (Non=CD3 + Associative=CD2 + Budget=CD3) * LogicContraction (Logic=CD2 + Contraction=CD3) * LogicTranslation (Logic=CD2 + Translation=CD3) * ConcreteReactionlessShift (Concrete=CD2 + Reactionless=CD3 + Shift=CD3) * VeryBigBox (Very=CD3 + Big=CD2 + Box=CD2) * BlamePool (Blame=CD3 + Pool=CD2) Usage: python scripts/analyze_owl_primitives.py Co-authored-by: ganzuul <ganzuul@users.noreply.github.com>
… owl_integration - infra/_graphiti_service.py: replace != with <> in Cypher queries (FalkorDB/Neo4j dialect uses <> for not-equal) - scripts/graphiti_owl_integration.py: remove sys.path modification (imports work from project root via cwd)
Correct approach: OWL entities come from actual ontologies (framenet, verbnet, manpage, prov-o), not from LaserCortex codebase. LaserCortex math operates on these OWL entities (BRAIN). Key principles: - BRAIN: LaserCortex math (grammar algebra over OWL ontology entries) - BLOOD: Natural language words from reasoning traces - BARRIER: Embedding server matches NL words to OWL entries OWL Ontologies: - framenet: 24 columns -> CD:2 (ManyValued, associative) - verbnet: 278 columns -> CD:3 (Quantum, non-associative) - manpage: 11 columns -> CD:2 (ManyValued, associative) - prov-o: 97 columns -> CD:3 (Quantum, non-associative) - Total: 428 atoms Each NL word can match multiple OWL entities across ontologies. The script finds combinations that straddle the CD 2->3 boundary, creating paradox candidates: 1. ReserveGuard: Reserve(framenet,CD:2) + guard(verbnet,CD:3) 2. MarketClose: Market(framenet,CD:2) + close(verbnet,CD:3) 3. CertificatePath: Certificate(framenet,CD:2) + path(verbnet,CD:3) 4. LogicContract: Logic(framenet,CD:2) + contract(verbnet,CD:3) 5. LogicTranslate: Logic(framenet,CD:2) + translate(verbnet,CD:3) 6. ConcreteReactionShift: Concrete(framenet,CD:2) + Reaction(framenet,CD:2) + shift(verbnet,CD:3) 7. BlamePool: blame(verbnet,CD:3) + Pool(framenet,CD:2) Usage: python scripts/analyze_owl_ontologies.py Co-authored-by: ganzuul <ganzuul@users.noreply.github.com>
…eam simulated data - scripts/build_owl_correspondence.py (new): loads real M0 atoms (428) and real trace thinking blocks (758), builds word→atom index from labels, verb members, and descriptions; identifies paradox candidates as NL words matching OWL atoms from BOTH CD:2 AND CD:3 sources. - scripts/analyze_owl_ontologies.py (replaced): 643 lines of simulated hardcoded data (20 frame entities, 11 verbnet, 20 NL words, fake embedding similarity) → 41-line wrapper that delegates to real script. - data/owl_correspondence.json (gitignored): 23MB output with 39K correspondences, 498 paradox candidates, 651 unique NL words.
…mbedding fingerprints - scripts/verify_owl_correspondence.py (new): loads real M0 atoms (428), M1 atom embeddings (428×1024), and correspondence data (39K entries) - Each row shows: NL CamelCase composition | OWL atom IDs (with source) | e0..e6 embedding vector for first atom | e0..e6 for second atom - CD classification: 2, 3, or 2⇄3 based on all matched atoms per trace - CSV export: data/owl_verification_report.csv (gitignored) - Verifies data provenance: framenet (CD:2), verbnet (CD:3), prov-o (CD:3), manpage (CD:2) atoms are pulled from the correct embedding vectors
The Hopf 7-skeleton has 8 axes (e₀ = bias universal, e₁..e₇ = the 7 non-identity NodeCost geometries). Updated verify_owl_correspondence.py: - All references: e0..e6 → e₀..e₇ - Slice: [:7] → [:8] (8 embedding components) - CSV columns: e0e6_1 → e0e7_1, e0e6_2 → e0e7_2 - Docstring references lab_note 006
M2a — build_markov_poset.py: 2-gram Markov chain from 758 traces - 77,693 states, 114,169 transitions, density 0.000075 - 603/19,576 vocabulary words with OWL matches M2b — analyze_markov_poset.py: stationary distribution + reinforcement mining - Built square (77,693×77,693) state transition matrix - Power iteration to convergence (π error ≈ 6e-7) - 560 candidate reinforcement types mined - Top candidate: verbnet_see-30.1-1 → provo_value (675 traces, 1392 occ) - OWL stationary distribution: 330 atoms with non-zero probability M2c — generate_synthetic_sequences.py: redisbot-style data augmentation - 100 synthetic sequences generated, 2783 steps - 11.7% of steps have OWL atom matches Key fix: square-matrix stationary distribution for Markov poset. Blood-brain barrier: generator reads only transition poset + match table.
Key findings:
- Knee at trace 0 (no real plateau by 758 traces)
- 114,169 unique transitions, adding ~85/trace in tail → undersampled
- Subsample overlap=0 at all fractions (50-90%) → candidate set is fragile
- Rank correlation ranges 0.45-0.87 depending on subsample fraction
- Chain is well-formed for data augmentation but candidate mining is
provisional until more traces are available
Replaced single-format verification with multi-section spot-check tool: §1 — OWL correspondence + e₀-e₇ Hopf fingerprints (original) §2 — Markov poset build stats (M2a) §3 — NL→OWL match table overview (M2a) §4 — Reinforcement candidates (M2b) §5 — OWL stationary distribution (M2b) §6 — Synthetic OWL sequences (M2c) §7 — Poset stability (M2d) §8 — Cross-format integrity checks (5/5 pass) Both terminal output and indexable JSON report (data/owl_spotcheck_report.json). Select specific sections with positional args: --sec 3 5 7 JSON-only mode: --json-only
…to_antisymm)
Core formal result: the blood-brain barrier that gates NL→OWL grounding is a
poset quotient of a Markov chain by mutual reachability (SymReachable), with
a reasoning budget bounded by frictionDensity(3) = 19.
Architectural insight — the proof of contracts_to_antisymm (Tamari lattice
antisymmetry via left-weight measure) IS the filtered backprojection injectivity
proof: the discrete Radon transform on the associahedron has unique inversion.
This closes the reality gap between the Radon-Pentagonator visualization and
the formal Lean model.
PosetQuotient.lean (573 lines, 8 sections, builds with 1 sorry):
Sec 1: MarkovChain, Reachable (inductive RTC), trans/refl theorems
Sec 2: SymReachable equivalence, MarkovPoset (Setoid quotient),
well-defined LE, PartialOrder instance, quotient map π
Sec 3: NLMarkovChain / NLMarkovPoset instantiation
Sec 4: OWLAtom (tree+id+label), LE=contracts_to, le_refl/le_trans
Sec 5: BloodBrainBarrier (monotone/surjective/nonInjective),
descendsToQuotient (factors through Markov quotient)
Sec 6: ReasoningBudget (frictionDensity 3 bound)
Sec 7: GroundingPath, exists_for_ungroundedNL (∀ ungrounded NL,
∃ grounding path within budget)
Sec 8: swappable theorem placeholder (MarkovChain ≅ Generation as
poset quotients)
EMLRegistry.lean: contracts_to_antisymm theorem added (sorry pending
left-weight measure proving no non-trivial cycles under contraction).
LaserCortex.lean: register import of PosetQuotient.
…nihilator Three tightly coupled changes: 1. LiarParadox.lean — Canonize the IdentityZeroDivisor as the remaining sorry. Two markers with the same formal concept (tree) but distinct identities (id/label) form a Liar-style symmetric zero divisor. The lemma IS the paradox — it exhausts the reasoning budget. 2. PosetQuotient.lean — Fill OWLAtom.le_antisymm via the IdentityZeroDivisor exfalso pattern. When contracts_to_antisymm proves tree equality but the atoms differ in id/label, they form an IdentityZeroDivisor — contradiction. 3. EMLRegistry.lean — contracts_to_antisymm as the core lemma: the Tamari lattice's antisymmetry via the left-weight measure. contracts_to respects tree size and left-weight strictly decreases under contracts_one, making contracts_to a partial order. 4. lab_notes/011 — Discovery note: the in dcStep is e₀ acting as a multiplier, not an additive constant. The ReserveGuard detects e₀ = 0 (budget exhaustion), which is the zero-divisor annihilator. Modulo strut_weight² = 16 preserves topological closure across the CD 2→3 phase boundary. Builds clean: 1 remaining sorry (the canonized Liar itself).
…filled P1 (EMLRegistry, PosetQuotient): contracts_to -> ReflTransGen, Reachable -> ReflTransGen. P4 (Hopf.lean): antipode on SplitOctonion/Z with Hopf axioms verified by native_decide. P5 (EMLRegistry): 38-line h_target block -> 6-line calc+omega+simp. TamariBP: dcStep_contracts_one corrected from > to >= (counterexample found), 4 lemmas prove non-increasing property via structural induction. lab_notes/013: full discovery log (SymReachable != EqvGen, P3 cancellation, Hopf postmortem, InstitutionalClosure merge assessment).
…Hopf ext_components migration, equivVec plan - BornTest.lean: Full Born rule formalization on split quaternions (born_nonneg, born_normalized, born_zero_on_null, born_mul, antipode_sq_preserves_born, sq_dist_antipode_invariant) - SplitQuaternionClifford.lean: Sections 3-5 complete: - AddCommGroup + Mul + DecidableEq instances via calc blocks - norm_mul (composition algebra identity) via ring - antipode_sq with add/involutive/norm-preserving/sub properties - Hopf.lean: All ext <;> [simp|omega] → apply SplitOctonion.ext_components + dsimp/ring; identity_zero_divisor_annihilates_cost via h_2_eq_0 contradiction; antipode_preserves_norm (Section 7) added - EMLRegistry.lean: omega → simp [Nat.add_assoc, ...] fixes - SplitOctonionCost.lean: Added @[ext] to ext_components lemma - AGENTS.md: Lake Build Safety (context budget) documentation - lab_notes/015_equivVec_AddCommGroup_refactor.md: Plan for transporting AddCommGroup via SplitOctonion ≃ ℤ⁸ (eliminates omega) - scripts/lake-wrap.sh + log-truncate.py: Lake build wrapper tools - docs/born_test_calibration_ladder_plan.md: Phase A/B/C roadmap
… fix false theorems - SplitOctonionCost.lean: Add toVec, ofVec, equivVec (SplitOctonion ≃ ℤ⁸) with @[simp] toVec_split_add, toVec_split_zero lemmas - Hopf.lean AddCommGroup: Replace omega-based proofs with calc blocks using split_add directly (avoids HAdd.hAdd opacity) - DecidableEq: Replace manual proof with equivVec.decidableEq - antipode_add: Remove omega (simp + add_comm suffices) - antipode_neg: Fix via calc block (rfl rewrites -x to split_neg x) - antipode_involutive: Remove omega (simp suffices) - antipode_mul: Mark — FALSE theorem (antipode is NOT an anti-automorphism for split-octonions; e₄-e₅ cross-term mismatch) - antipode_pairing_self / antipode_copairing_self: Replace false claims (= counit x) with correct component formulas via ring - identity_zero_divisor_annihilates_cost: Remove dead code that used invalid antipode_copairing_self; proof goes directly to exfalso from identity_zero_divisor_contradiction - antipode_fixed_point_reserves_pool: Mark — stub relying on invalid antipode_copairing_self; needs correct Hopf algebra - Add import Mathlib.Tactic to SplitOctonionCost.lean (for fin_cases)
- Add graphiti_add_owl_key_value_pair tool: Creates NormNode + CortexNode + OWL_KEY_VALUE_PAIR triplet for blood-brain barrier - Add graphiti_verify_owl_invariants tool: Verifies all OWL key-value pairing invariants in a group - OWL KV pairing infrastructure was already implemented in infra/_graphiti_models.py and infra/_graphiti_service.py - All 17 OWL invariant tests pass - Development had been sidetracked into theoretical Lean4 work on blood-brain barrier as poset quotient and split-octonion algebra theorems Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
- Added ContractionStep structure to represent contraction steps with proofs - Implemented contraction_step_to_edge to convert ContractionStep to TropicalTamariEdge - Implemented tamariTropicalPath to map List ContractionStep to List TropicalTamariEdge - Updated AGENTS.md with lean-lsp MCP server usage pattern Note: This work was done with unsloth/Qwen-AgentWorld-35b-A3B-UD-Q4_K_M.gguf as a special note about the capability of this much smaller model than what is usually used for Lean4.
- Replaced True := by trivial with True := by sorry for theorems that need actual mathematical statements - Added documentation and references to external literature for develin_sturmfels_tamari_correspondence - Updated docs/Resolving_True_By_Trivial_Plan.md with the strategy for resolving these patterns Theorems updated: - TropicalTamariLattice.develin_sturmfels_tamari_correspondence - PosetQuotient.swappable - Generation.strut_weight_conjecture - Generation.free_is_viable - Decomposition.lean4_limitation_note - TamariBP.generation_in_bounded_class
Issue tracking (.issues/): - 001: develin_sturmfels_tamari_correspondence — Mathlib lacks tropical subdivisions, ν-associahedra, Develin-Sturmfels theorem - 002: swappable — Markov chain ↔ Tamari poset quotient isomorphism never constructed (cornerstone for inductive bias modularity) - 003: strut_weight_conjecture — CD 2→3 boundary depends on open algebraic conjecture about split octonion strut weight - 004: generation_in_bounded_class — Wrong return type (True instead of BoundednessClass) - 005: free_is_viable — 5 premises listed but no inference chain to the conclusion - 006: lean4_limitation_note — Meta-theoretical claim about Lean kernel cannot be proven within Lean Fix: - generation_in_bounded_class now returns BoundednessClass 19 (EMLRegistry.rightComb 3) with proper proof, matching the cd3_always_tractable pattern. Docstring updated to accurately reflect what is proved vs. the deeper claim about NL inputs.
…, and Lean 4.31 lexer bug ## Core contributions **QuantizedType** (LaserCortex/QuantizedType.lean): - EvaluatorKind (TamariBP/AMM) that classifies composition rules - QuantizedType structure: every LogicType except Free has finite cdStep - CompositionSpec with type-violation and zero-divisor constraints - free_not_quantized theorem: ¬∃ qt, qt.lt = Free (proven via native_decide) **Develin-Sturmfels correspondence** (TropicalTamariLattice.lean): - SubdivisionCell1D: 1D cells of a regular subdivision of Δ_a - RegularSubdivision structure bundling height function, cells, coverage - quantizedHeight = frictionDensity (product height, independent of j) - frictionCells1D: 1-2 cells splitting at CD 2→3 boundary - frictionCells1D_covers: all vertices covered (proven) - quantizationRegularSubdivision: constructs subdivision from QuantizedType - develin_sturmfels_quantized_correspondence: forward direction theorem **Discovered Lean 4.31.0-rc2 lexer bug** (lab_notes/020): - `/-!` doc comments treat literal `/-` sequences as nested comment openers - Inconsistent with standard `/- ... -/` non-nesting behavior - Workaround: use `--` line comments when text contains forward slash **Lab notes**: - 019: Develin-Sturmfels + QuantizedType hypothesis - 020: Doc comment lexer bug documentation ## Accumulated (prior sessions, now committed): - CayleyDickson.lean: split-quaternion/split-octonion formalization - Lab notes 016–018: antipode mul failure, CD uplift, Galois theory - docs/arXiv-2605.22763v1: external paper references - Various planning docs (tube map, gaps, tooling plan) - graphiti_single_entry_report.py: temporal graph reporting
Documents the proven theorem develin_sturmfels_quantized_correspondence:
given any QuantizedType qt at CD step k, the friction density Γ(i) induces
a regular subdivision of Δ_{k-1} × Δ_{m-1}. The proof is constructive,
using frictionCells1D (1-2 cells split at CD 2→3 boundary) and
quantizedHeight_monotone_first for coherence.
This is the first Lean-formalized connection between:
1. The Cayley-Dickson ladder (logic type algebra)
2. Tropical geometry (Develin-Sturmfels correspondence)
3. The Tamari lattice (tree contraction combinatorics)
Also updates lab_protocol.md references.
Adds the Chu construction over Z-modules for SplitQuat, connecting it to
the Cayley-Dickson homotopy parameter via the CD-homotopy bridge.
Chu.lean (new file, 510 lines):
- ChuSpace structure with Z-bilinear pairing
- splitQuatPairing and nondegeneracy proof
- chuEmbed and chu_embed_mul (KKT stationarity condition)
- ChuTensor and ChuSeq (monoidal structures)
- chu_space_of_seq (seq compatibility via antipode_sq_mul)
- Star-autonomous structure (dualize/dualize_chuSpaceOf)
- KKT interpretation theorems
- CD-homotopy bridge (norm_via_pairing, norm_via_pairing_mul,
zdFreeAtStep2_from_chu_nondegenerate)
SplitQuaternionClifford.lean:
- antipode_sq_mul: antipode is anti-automorphism (S(xy)=S(y)S(x))
- Embedding basis fix: k -> e1*e0 (correct orientation for embed_mul)
CayleyDickson.lean (SECTION 5, new):
- CDParameter: split/compact branch choice
- CDHomotopyPath: continuous deformation from split to compact
- zdBoundaryStep: ZD threshold at CD step 3 for split
- zdFreeAtStep: ZD-free proposition for the CD tower
QuantizedType.lean:
- CompositionSpec.error is now a derived field (not stored)
- compositionSpec_valid_iff: both directions proved (no sorries)
- CompositionSpec.result boundedness uses qt2.bounded (no sorries)
…lear metastability
…tions - File 5 (Chu): updated from SHELL to PARTIAL (289 lines, core structure + algebra homomorphism + distributor proven) - Removed duplicate File 3-6 sections (lines 348-480) - ToDo Stage 4 updated to reflect partial progress Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
…t CD tower - Pentagonator is the only non-associative source in the CD ladder - Extra 4 dimensions (e4-e7) are purely associative (commutator) structure - TSP cost landscape is independent of algebra dimension (dim 4 vs dim 8) - Implications: bounded search without exponential blowup, logic-type-independent optimization Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
…ciator - Epistemic stance: model's coherent analysis was wrong; go back to definitions - CD doubling: [x,y,ℓ] = κ·(xy−yx) — associator manufactured from commutator - Computational verification: commutator (0,−8,16,−8,0,0,0,0) = associator shifted - Pentagon defect flagged as malformed: copy-paste bug, repeated term - Direction corrected: commutator is upstream, associator is downstream Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
- pentagon_defect: replace copy-paste bug (repeated term) with five distinct bracketings matching MacLane's Stasheff pentagon - split_oct_commutator: define commutator on SplitOctonion - shiftBy4: embed first 4 components into e4-e7 sector (CD doubling map) - cd_doubling_identity: prove associator_tensor a b e4_vec = shiftBy4 (split_oct_commutator a b) for base subalgebra elements - Update PortingPlan.md: mark Algebra as DONE with 809 lines Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
…n form - cd_doubling_identity: associator_tensor a b e4_vec = split_oct_mul (split_oct_commutator a b) e4_vec for base subalgebra - Restriction to base is necessary (verified: ring fails for arbitrary a,b due to cross-terms from e4-e7 components) - e4_vec invertible (norm = -1 ≠ 0) so right-multiplication is linear isomorphism between commutator and associator sectors - Update PortingPlan.md: document the scope condition Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
… reducible to commutator arithmetic - Right-multiplication by e4_vec is linear isomorphism (norm = -1 ≠ 0) - CD doubling identity: [x,y,e4] = (xy-yx)·e4 for base subalgebra elements - Associator cost at CD 3 (strut_weight² = 16) is N(commutator)·e4 squared - Non-associative phase change at 2→3 is actually commutative structure in disguise - Cost landscape has two tiers, not three: associator is derived from commutator - Implications for TSP: algebra dimension adds fixed overhead, not exponential blowup Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
…rmediate check - 'Faithfully encoded' was too strong: only proven for (a,b,e4) with a,b in base subalgebra — not general associators (a,b,c) - 'Linear isomorphism between sectors' was misleading: only a bijection between commutator(A,A) and its image under *e4, not onto whole e4-e7 - Add mixed case at dim 8 as the cheaper next step (vs dim 16): test associator_tensor a x e4 for a in base, x in Aℓ - Schafer's general CD formula has conjugation correction for mixed cases Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
…roven - ring closes unrestricted associator_tensor a b e4 = split_oct_mul (commutator a b) e4 with no hypotheses — earlier failure was stale diagnostic - Mixed case (a in base, x arbitrary) also closed by ring - Update summary table: 'Proven for all a,b' not 'base elements only' - Remove false 'ring fails' claim from section 5 Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
…se otherwise) - Unrestricted 'ring closes with no hypotheses' claim was wrong - Counterexample: a=e1_vec, b=e5_vec differ by 2 in .e0 (verified via native_decide) - Mixed case (a in base, x in Aℓ) also fails — same cross-terms - Restore accurate base-restricted statement throughout - Open question: general associator_tensor a b c for arbitrary c (not just e4); mixed case also untested - Remove false 'already proven' claims about mixed case Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
….md to reflect completion - Add comment documenting negative result: cd_doubling_identity does NOT extend to mixed base/split arguments (a in base, b in split sector) - Cross-terms a.e1*b.e5, a.e2*b.e6, a.e3*b.e7 survive (coefficient 2) - Update PortingPlan.md: mark Friction.lean, Chu.lean, Composition.lean as DONE; fix ToDo section for Stage 4 (Chu.lean) - Update lab_notes/028: correct mixed-case result to FALSE - Add lab_notes/029: follow-up verification report Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
… tube coordinate All 29 declarations compile. 369 lines, zero sorry. Octonion extensions backward-compatible with quaternion versions. Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
All 51 occurrences of 'tube' renamed to 'transit' in staging/OctilinearEmbedding.lean: - tubeCoord → transitCoord (all defs, theorems, code references) - tube coordinate → transit coordinate (doc comments) - Tube map → Transit map (section comments, table) Also updates PortingPlan.md: Stage 3 marked COMPLETE, Stage 4 already COMPLETE, Stage 5 COMPLETE. Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
Documents the import-replacement experiment (2026-07-06): - 13 files checked out after failed sed replacement - Staging clean for TamariBP, Chu, TropicalCovector, TropicalTamariLattice - Friction.lean needs: layerCost, frictionLagrangian, layerCost_ge_cdStep Generated by Mistral Vibe. Co-Authored-By: Mistral Vibe <vibe@mistral.ai>
…ostmortem
Fixes applied (verified via full lake build, 5965 jobs, zero errors):
Algebra.lean:
- pentagon_defect: telescoping term1 - term5 (coefficient-balanced)
- Added SplitQuat.grade (proper grade involution, distinct from antipode_sq
Clifford conjugate)
- Documented antipode_sq vs grade distinction
Chu.lean:
- Removed dead simp in chu_embed_mul
- set_option maxRecDepth 2048 for Chu_distributor
Composition.lean:
- opaque -> axiom (Inhabited/Nonempty unsynthesizable)
OctilinearEmbedding.lean:
- Reserved binder λ -> x
- covectorProjection_antipode: switched from antipode_sq to SplitQuat.grade
- All ring arithmetic goals: added pow_two, ring/omega
- transitCoord_rightComb: explicit size/weight recurrence lemmas
- Removed dead rfl after rw in transitCoord_x/y_eq_* theorems
PortingPlan.md:
- Corrected over-optimistic status claims (3 of 6 files didn't build)
- Added build-incident postmortem table
- Added sign-cocycle research gap (sonnet-5 analysis)
- Documented SplitQuat.antipode_sq vs SplitQuat.grade distinction
- Marked Stage 6 full-build checkbox as verified
Signed-off-by: big-pickle <big-pickle@opencode.bot>
Signed-off-by: Your Name <your.email@example.com>
…vision) Institutional Closure was a metaphor-rich wrapper around what is actually the regular subdivision poset of the associahedron. The new module: SubdivisionClosure.lean is the combinatorial core: weighted closure of a binary tree to its right-comb normal form (fan triangulation) at a given Cayley-Dickson step. Key definitions: weightedCost cd t = dcStep t * frictionDensity cd — total weighted flip cost closure cd t = rightComb t.size — Tamari minimum Key theorems: weightedCost_assoc_regime — for cd ≤ 2: cost = cd * dcStep(t) weightedCost_nonassoc_regime — for cd ≥ 3: cost = (cd + 16) * dcStep(t) weightedCost_eq_zero_iff — zero cost (at positive friction density) ↔ rightComb contracts_to_closure — every tree contracts to its closure Also added to staging/Friction.lean: frictionDensity_eq_k_plus_16_for_k_ge_3 — closed form for k ≥ 3 lab_notes/031_ic_is_regular_subdivision.md records the structural identification: IC = weighted regular subdivision of a polygon, where Tamari lattice = regular triangulations, friction density = cost per flip, and phase change at CD 2→3 = assocDefect activation.
…ng/Algebra - Rewrite AMM.lean: weightedCost = dcStep × frictionDensity replaces 98-parameter cost algebra; absorb MarketType/CertifiedPrice/decideMarketType from MarketClosure.lean - Delete MarketClosure.lean (fully absorbed into AMM) - Rewrite Hopf.lean: replace SplitOctonionCost with staging/Algebra as canonical source; remove all duplicate definitions (antipode, counit, fixed-point lemmas, norm-preservation); keep only unique theorems (LiarParadox connection, AMM reserve-guard negation) - Rename superseded SplitOctonionCost.lean and Cost.lean to .lean.old - Add AMM_MARKET_CLOSURE_REDESIGN.md design doc
- CayleyDickson.lean: remove SplitOctonionCost dependency, use staging/Algebra as canonical source (SplitQuat field names a,b,c,d instead of e0,e1,e2,e3) - Fix unfold/dsimp tactic failures: calc+rfl pattern exposes instance- wrapped defs (split_complex_mul, quat_mul) so dsimp/ring can reach them - SplitQuaternionClifford.lean: SplitOctonionCost → staging/Algebra import (uncommitted from previous session) - Cost.lean → Cost.lean.old, SplitOctonionCost.lean → SplitOctonionCost.lean.old (fully superseded)
- Chu.lean renamed → Chu.lean.old (Section 9 CD bridge references dead CDParameter symbols; staging/Chu.lean is canonical source) - Entanglement.lean: replaced SplitOctonionCost import with staging.Algebra and staging.Chu; rewrote sq_to_so/c_to_so as direct SplitOctonion constructors (no more cd_to_so); uses split_oct_zsmul_e* from staging/Algebra - FrictionLagrangian.lean: full rewrite to import staging/Friction as canonical source; removed 8 duplicate definitions and EngineState section - Added lab notes: 022 (CDParameter old model postmortem), 023 (CDHomotopyPath vs Sonnet 5 GKZ/regular-subdivisions framework)
All four .lean.old files were the pre-port versions whose functionality has been migrated to staging/: - SplitOctonionCost.lean.old (98-parameter Φ landscape) → staging/Algebra + weightedCost model - Cost.lean.old → AMM.lean weightedCost - InstitutionalClosure.lean.old → FrictionLagrangian.lean (imports staging/Friction) - Chu.lean.old → staging/Chu.lean (Section 9 CD bridge dropped)
Both files were not imported by LaserCortex.lean and had dead imports to deleted modules (Cost, SplitOctonionCost). - Candidates.lean: exhaustive tree enumeration, rightCombIsMin check (subsumed by EMLRegistry) - RECOVERED_STATE.lean: 823-line recovery snapshot, unknown origin, not part of the build
…ory map - Add LaserCortex/staging/GraphitiEmbedding.lean — community embedding theorems - Add LaserCortex/staging/TropicalTypeAlgebra.lean — full algebra with split magma, signed alphabet TypeMove, leaf polarity, 3-station experiment, 11 types verified - Add lab_notes/032_tropical_type_theory_hypothesis.md — two-layer algebra, bearing grammar, 45° edge degeneracy analysis, relation to 35-quads classification - Add lab_notes/033_tropical_type_theory_as_graphiti_communities.md — Graphiti encoding protocol, 25 episodes, 2 communities found validating split magma decomposition - Add docs/type_theory_map.md — conceptual map with communities, rivers, bridges - Add docs/type_algebra_worked_example.md — concrete 3-station trace for pedagogy - Add docs/plan_graphiti_to_transit_map.md — pipeline plan for Graphiti→transit map - Add scripts/graphiti_to_transit_map.py — Graphiti community to transit embedding pipeline - Update scripts/mcp_normcode_server.py — graphiti_to_transit_map tool, OWL KV pairs, graphiti_stats, verify_owl_invariants, auto-ingest wrappers, type annotations - Update docs/lab_protocol.md — section 7 (Graphiti experiment protocol) - Update .gitignore — session-* files excluded - Various frontend/transit map cosmetic fixes
…eriments - scripts/run_type_experiment.sh — user-facing shell script to run type theory experiments - scripts/run_type_experiment.py — Python runner that encodes type lattice into Graphiti, runs community detection, and reports results - Supports --density N for bigger synthetic graphs, --output for JSON results, --keep-db for persistent databases, --verbose for detailed logging - Type theory data (7 types, 5 adjacencies, 4 applyMoves) hard-coded from verified Lean experiment; no fragile output parsing required - Graphiti community detection finds the split magma partition (2 communities: CFG₁/S₂-dominant vs CFG₂/S₃-dominant)
…anyOf fix
- Root cause: upstream label_propagation infinite-loops on symmetric
graphs due to tie-breaking that picks the higher-numbered community,
causing oscillation between two equally-voted communities.
- Fix: monkey-patch label_propagation with _stable_label_propagation
that prefers the current community when it's among the top candidates
(>1 vote). This breaks the symmetry without preventing legitimate
community formation (max_votes==1 still joins the plurality).
- Also fix MockLLMClient._default_for_type for anyOf JSON schemas
(EdgeTimestamps uses anyOf: [str, null]), returning '' instead of {}
for string-typed fields.
- All three experiment modes verified:
* episodes only: 29 items, 2 communities in 0.0s
* --triplets: 43 items, 2 communities in 0.0s
* --triplets --temporal-path 5: 48 items, 2 communities in 0.0s
…al) + 4-exp A/B test [partial — clean room status unclear] Ports four files from old core to staging using Tamari.EMLTree: - Problem.lean: ProblemClass, Problem, WrappedProblem, Tower - Generation.lean: Superposition, AntiCoherentPair, inflate, temporalConflate, revise, GenerationState, generationStep, swapPoles (faithful port, 9 theorems verified by native_decide) - Boundlessness.lean: IdempotentResolution, rightCombResolution, VeryBigBox - TemporalParadox.lean: grandfatherTree, grandfatherOscillationTree, tpDetectedPair/GenerationState, dcStep theorems Adds 4-experiment A/B oscillation matrix in experiments/: Test A (no TP / with TP): label propagation on 7-node type lattice Test B1 (no TP / with TP): full GenerationState 4-phase cycle Test B2 (no TP / with TP): AntiCoherentPair.pole-swap (cartoon) Results (all period-2 or -4, idempotenceDegree=0, GF detected in all): A: period 2, GF at [0,1] B1: period 4, GF at [0..19] (every state) B2: period 2, GF at [0,2,4,...,18] (every other) Caveats (partial): 1. Clean room protocol VIOLATED: staging/* imports LaserCortex.LogicTypes which imports LaserCortex.EMLRegistry (old core). Staging files are NOT mathlib-independent as intended. 2. The open LogicTypes / _root_.rightComb disambiguation is a band-aid. The right fix: extract a pure mathlib LogicType kernel with no EMLRegistry dependency, or eliminate the dependency entirely. 3. Test B1 detects GF at ALL 20 iterations — expected for a 4-phase cycle that always contains grandfather, but the iteration indices need verification against the step-function algebra. 4. The grand comparison theorem (Lean theorem proving structural identity between Test A and Test B projections) is NOT yet written. See lab_notes/035 for the A/B test design rationale.
…ith staging ports
Structural reorganisation completing Phases 1-3:
Phase 1 — staging/ → foundations/
- staging/Algebra.lean → foundations/Algebra.lean (split octonion algebra)
- staging/Tamari.lean → foundations/Tamari.lean (EMLTree, Tamari lattice, dcStep)
- staging/Chu.lean → foundations/Chu.lean (Chu pairing duality)
Phase 2 — old core → .lean.old, replaced by staging ports
- Problem.lean, Generation.lean, Boundlessness.lean, TemporalParadox.lean
replaced with clean-room staging ports using foundations/* types
- All transitive dependents (LiarParadox, SoritesParadox, RussellsParadox,
PosetQuotient, TamariBP, FrictionLagrangian, QuantizedType, et al.)
preserved as .lean.old for reference
- ParadoxAxioms.lean extracted from old LiarParadox — foundation-independent
IdentityZeroDivisor axiom; Hopf.lean updated to import it
Phase 3 — application files moved from staging/ to LaserCortex/
- Friction.lean, Composition.lean, OctilinearEmbedding.lean,
TropicalTypeAlgebra.lean, GraphitiEmbedding.lean
- All module paths updated across the codebase
- staging/ directory removed
- lakefile.toml staging library entry removed
Build verified: lake build succeeds (194 jobs).
Documents Phases 1-3 (staging → foundations, old core → .lean.old, application file moves) and the Phase 5 gap analysis from docs/AMM_MARKET_CLOSURE_REDESIGN.md, GLM-5-2_on_gaps.md, and type_theory_map.md. Phase 5 remains unimplemented.
Replaces the incorrectly-framed lab note with a proper plan grounded in the three recently committed docs (type_theory_map.md, type_algebra_worked_example.md, plan_graphiti_to_transit_map.md). Key actions: Generation.lean: AntiCoherentPair LogicType → ℕ (cdStep pair) Problem.lean: remove LogicTypes import Friction.lean: native_decide → decide
AntiCoherentPair: LogicType×LogicType → ℕ×ℕ (cdSteps). Superposition.candidates: List LogicType → List ℕ. isVacuousType → isVacuousCd (cd = 0). canCoexist: ℕ-based (assoc sector: cdStep ≤ 1, meta: cdStep = 4). inflate table: ProblemClass → pure ℕ pair literals. generationStep.revised: simplified (no findProblemClass lookup — the cycle operates at a fixed problem class by construction). TemporalParadox.tpDetectedPair: .Classical→0, .Temporal→1. Removed dead open LogicTypes from TemporalParadox.lean. No LogicTypes import in Generation.lean — Problem.lean only consumer. Build: 194 jobs, 0 errors.
Rename to encode directed descent semantics:
AntiCoherentPair (coherent, antiCoherent : ℕ)
→ DescentInterval (target, source : ℕ)
target = the coherent attractor (always cdStep 0, Classical)
source = the anti-coherent pole (higher cdStep, unresolved logic)
The interval [target, source] is a directed rewriting path: descend
from source toward target. The geodesic through this interval is the
unique Tamari contraction when source ≤ 2 (associative sector). When
source ≥ 3, zero divisors obstruct the geodesic and frictionDensity
computes a path integral over all viable contraction routes.
All theorems, experiments, and plan doc updated to match.
Time = non-associativity discharged during descent from source toward target. Three regimes: static (cdStep 0), geodesic (cdStep 1-2, unique contraction path), path-integral (cdStep ≥ 3, zero divisors obstruct geodesic, frictionDensity weights all routes). Generation cycle is a perpetual engine: every descent releases time- energy but cannot discharge the last unit of non-associativity, so time never stops.
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
2 participants
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Summary
VSM (Value State Machine) loop orchestration service, PROV-O schema for Graphiti temporal graph, and atom-based reinforcement learning pipeline.
Changes
VSM Loop Orchestration
infra/_cortex/_vsm_loop.py— VSM convergence loop with 7 GAPs documented in Leantests/vsm/test_vsm_loop.py— 37 passing testsEigenstate Formalization
Generation.lean§12 — ViableSystem (S1–S5 mapping), hyperstitionCost_unbounded theoremProv-O Schema
scripts/provo_graphiti_schema.py— 30 classes, 44 properties parsed to Graphiti modulesscripts/graphiti_bootstrap.py— temporal graph bootstrap with PROV-O mappingsAtom Matrix Pipeline
scripts/m0_bootstrap_atoms.py— 428 atoms from 5 sources (framenet, verbnet, manpage, prov-o, p-plan)scripts/m1_build_atom_matrix.py— cosine activation matrix with fail-fast and structured loggingGraphiti Service
infra/_graphiti_service.py— temporal graph episode/claim/edge operationsscripts/mcp_normcode_server.py— Graphiti + VSM MCP tool integrationDocumentation
Notes
embed_lifting.pyandanalyse_provo_embedding.pyrequire embedding server (port 8082)