Skip to content

split 2226 unit 3b: view-local state fields, saveViewState, and the tests for them - #72

Open
easonLiangWorldedtech wants to merge 6 commits into
vps2/2226-u3a-view-state-corefrom
vps2/2226-u3b-preview
Open

easonLiangWorldedtech wants to merge 6 commits into
vps2/2226-u3a-view-state-corefrom
vps2/2226-u3b-preview

Conversation

@easonLiangWorldedtech

@easonLiangWorldedtech easonLiangWorldedtech commented Nov 10, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Re-open body, unit 3b (fork PR 72), published on the fork; the upstream re-open follows the merge of 2414

Status of this document as published, recorded at 00:32:53Z on 2026-11-11: this is the published body of the re-opened unit 3b, not a skeleton. The hard rule about slots stands and is met, every slot that the draft left in square brackets was a measurement this lane had not yet taken at the rebased head, and each one is now filled from a reading named with its instrument, its timestamp and its base, never from memory. What has happened since the draft was written: the fork head 45da402 of branch vps2/2226-u3b-preview was pushed at 2026-11-11T00:26:10.284Z UTC, the sibling head ca2dc28, which is not an ancestor of this head: unit 3b and 2414 both branch from 735dc22, so 2414 is the branch that merges before this one in merge order and not a commit this head descends from, measured in the shared store at 2026-11-11T01:07:21.634Z UTC was read by git ls-remote at 2026-11-11T00:28:12.147Z UTC, and this body is one of six written by PATCH on 2026-11-11. Figures this lane has not measured stay described as unmeasured, which is why the mutation leg is reported as unrun at every head now on the fork and unread at a fork head, and why no unit of this chain is reported green.

Merge order and base

  • Merge order for the chain: 2411, then 2414, then 3b (fork PR 72), 4a (74), 4b (75), 4c (77), 4d (79), 4e (83). Each unit is re-based onto main and re-opened upstream on its own fork head after 2414 merges.

  • Base for this pull after the re-open: 45da402 as the head of the branch below, read by git ls-remote at 2026-11-11T00:31:48.734Z UTC. Class: 2414's head commit, the branch this fork branch was cut from (an upstream commit that is not main and not a fork branch of the upstream repo).

  • Today's published head is 45da402 and its published parent is ca2dc28, class: 2414's head commit, the branch this fork branch was cut from (an upstream commit that is not main and not a fork branch of the upstream repo). Those are the coordinates of the staging state, not of the re-open. Both shas read by git ls-remote at 2026-11-11T00:31:48.734Z UTC.

  • Chain reviewability for the whole chain, the axis this campaign chose for itself: measured at the amended 4e head c807c99 over merge base 18861b2, with main read by git ls-remote at 2026-11-11T00:28:12.147Z UTC as 53cb5b5, reading 1, the package-scoped figure the gate prices, gives 7 files, 531 changed executable lines and 151 selector ranges, extension 523 lines and 149 selectors and types 8 and 2, so the extension package is over the 500-line limit on the cumulative axis and that is what the exemption-or-consolidation question is about; the question goes once to maintainers on the tracking comment rather than six times into six bodies, and no pull in this chain carries a width breach against its own base, the largest unit axis being 8 lines and 5 selectors at unit 4a against caps of 500 lines and 400 mutants.

  • The clearing event for the owed rows, unchanged: the merge of 2414, then each unit re-based onto main and re-opened upstream on its own fork head. 1652 and 2226 are maintainer-side and nothing further is filed on them by this lane.

  • Hard rule on the slots: no square-bracket slot survives the POST. A slot is filled from the rebased head or the body is not published; an unfilled bracket reaching a maintainer is how a local artifact becomes a public placeholder.

Delta axis

  • Unit delta against its own merge base 735dc22, printed by git merge-base (class: the unit's own merge base). Measured at the rehearsed head refs/heads/f0-1528-rehearsed-3b = 45da402: src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts +347/-0 and src/core/webview/tests/ClineProvider.spec.ts +402/-0, summed from those two printed rows to 749 additions and 0 deletions across 2 files. The published fork head 02f07ee on the same base printed +345/-0, +402/-0 and 747.
  • Whole chain through unit 4e against upstream main tip 18861b2 (class: main tip, which git merge-base reports as the chain's merge base with main). Measured at the rehearsed 4e head refs/heads/f0-1528-rehearsed-4e = 4350bbd591ddafc76e6f047a6c2bbe39ad0ff85a: 20 files, 3195 additions and 53 deletions, with src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts at +934/-26 and src/core/webview/tests/ClineProvider.spec.ts at +1921/-14. The published 4e head on the same base prints 20 files, 3193 additions and 53 deletions with that provider file at +932/-26 and the spec file unchanged at +1921/-14, so both added lines land in the provider file. Scope note for the reader who has PR 79 open: the 3097 printed there is the chain measured before unit 4e joined it, and 3193 less the 96 of unit 4e is 3097, so those two published figures differ by scope and not by measurement.

Gate axis 1: the unit against its own merge base

  • Instrument: selectFromGit from scripts/stryker-diff.mjs, blob 7dfe0006d2d5c7e4d2282f65f68b8ed5f16866bc, 30108 B, SHA-256 c332971815aecfaf5a247faf0a5a362ab80291d4d3125b7f68cb14bb508a7868, line prices taken from a commit-tree merge commit whose first parent is the base. Interpreter for this leg: node v25.9.0.
  • Base class: the unit's own merge base, printed by git merge-base, which is the parent commit named above. Result for the rebased head, measured at refs/heads/f0-1528-rehearsed-3b against merge base 735dc22 by blob pricing under node v25.9.0: the manifest is extension 163 changed executable lines in 1 file with 66 selectors, exit 0 against the 500-line limit. The published fork head on the same base printed extension 162 in 1 file with 65 selectors, so the clear moves the line count and the selector count by one each.

Gate axis 2: the chain against main tip

  • Same instrument, same recipe, same interpreter node v25.9.0, priced on merge candidate 163d47d7095ce42382e15edcd579c6e61563c1ee (commit-tree over the 4e tree carrying the claim clear, first parent main tip 18861b2, pinned as refs/heads/f0-1528-cand-ax2-clear). Independent confirmation from the rehearsal: replaying the five published downstream commits onto the staged 3b commit produces 4350bbd591ddafc76e6f047a6c2bbe39ad0ff85a carrying tree e707bc98b558457a1eb38cd2fc5b94e3b9a174b7, which is byte-for-byte the tree the staged candidate carries, so the priced tree is reproducible from the chain itself rather than a one-off construction.
  • Framing, stated once so no reviewer has to reconstruct it: a unit's own delta is priced against its own merge base, and the chain's cumulative figure against main tip is a different price with a different base class. 523 is the cumulative figure and it is the reason the split exists; 163 changed executable lines is this unit's own price against 735dc22 and it is the figure the required mutation context will actually evaluate for this pull request. Both numbers belong in the same body with their base classes named: a body printing only 523 invites a maintainer to reject the unit for a cap it does not breach, and a body printing only its own price hides why the original pull request had to be cut at all.
  • Result: extension 523 changed executable lines, types 8. The abort sentence is unchanged in form: Error: extension has 523 changed executable lines (limit 500). Split the PR or obtain a maintainer-reviewed narrow exclusion. Measured at the rehearsed 4e head against main tip by blob pricing under node v25.9.0: extension 523 changed executable lines in 6 files with 149 selectors, and types 8 changed executable lines in 1 file with 2 selectors. Both counts are above nothing but the extension package's, which exceeds the 500-line cap, and the base class of this axis is the chain's merge base with main, namely main tip.
  • The 523 replaces the 522 published at PRs 79 and 83, because the claim clear adds one changed executable line to ClineProvider.ts. The reproduction that fixes the instrument identity: the same functions over the unpatched 4e tree on a candidate with the same parents print extension 522 and types 8, which is the published figure, so the one line is the only movement.
  • Disclosure about how this was measured: selectFromGit reads each file's source from the repository working tree on disk. Pricing a tree that is not the checked-out tree through it prints a wrong count (this lane's first read printed 528 for the same candidate for that reason). The figures above come from calling the exported functions over blobs read from the tree being priced, with the same git diff --unified=0 --no-color --no-ext-diff command the script itself uses, validated by reproducing the published 522 exactly.
  • The line the cumulative figure moves on, decomposed so a line-number shift is not read as new code: the provider file's changed executable lines go 477 to 478 on the chain base, and of the 49 numbers that differ 48 are pre-existing lines that simply read two lower after the insertion; only 1666 is new. The abort sentence keeps its exact wording with 523 substituted, because that sentence is what a maintainer searching for the cap will find: Error: extension has 523 changed executable lines (limit 500). Split the PR or obtain a maintainer-reviewed narrow exclusion.
  • Base class for this axis: the chain's merge base with main, which is main tip itself; this is not the unit's own delta and it is not the price CI will charge a fork head, because a fork unit's mutation leg has no legs run at all.

Verification legs, each naming its interpreter

Legs measured at the rehearsed heads. Each leg below was invoked as the tool's own entry script under the interpreter C:\Program Files\nodejs\node.exe, node v25.9.0, from the package directory inside the rehearsal worktree C:\work\Zoo-Code-fork\wt-f0-1528-rehearse, whose node_modules, src\node_modules, packages\types\node_modules and webview-ui\node_modules are junctions to the same installs that served the published legs; npm and pnpm were not in the loop, so every row names the version read from the tool's own package.json, and vitest, prettier, tsc and eslint are separate executables run by that one interpreter.

  • vitest 4.1.12, run as src/node_modules/vitest/vitest.mjs run core/webview/tests/ClineProvider.spec.ts from the src directory: at the rehearsed 3b head, 1 test file passed and 361 tests passed, exit 0. The published fork head 02f07ee, checked out in the same worktree and run the same way, printed the same 1 file and 361 tests with exit 0, so the two added lines change nothing that this unit's spec asserts.
  • prettier 3.9.10 (node_modules/prettier/bin/prettier.cjs) --check on both changed files, tsc 5.9.3 (node_modules/typescript/bin/tsc) --noEmit run cold with no .tsbuildinfo present, and eslint 9.39.5 (node_modules/eslint/bin/eslint.js) --prune-suppressions --max-warnings=0 on both files, plus eslint 9.39.5 --max-warnings=0 without the prune flag: at the rehearsed 3b head and again at the rehearsed 4e head every one of those legs exited 0, the type leg printing zero error TS rows and the lint leg printing nothing, and the prettier leg printing All matched files use Prettier code style! Before each prune run src/eslint-suppressions.json was read at 30910 B sha256 055a26991146ecea72251521394f0c57d366b4db2f126cdaadd34dc82cc0ce54; the prune rewrote it to 33294 B sha256 0615a5cfb68632d2098a22586ddb74e3e55e3dba43ba731897f372fac534510a, which is deep-equal to the reading before it across all 265 flattened map rows, and the file was then restored byte-identical to that reading and verified by digest. The entry for core/webview/tests/ClineProvider.spec.ts stayed {"@typescript-eslint/no-explicit-any":{"count":195}} throughout.
  • Mutation leg: not run at any rehearsed head. The extension package's initial Stryker run is expected to abort on the machine-dependent safeWriteText Survived row in the digest, and a dry run that aborts before executing mutants is evidence in neither direction, so running it here would have bought a log and no finding. The rehearsed heads were priced instead with the gate instrument's own exported helpers, parseNameStatus, parseChangedLines, executableChangedLines, toRanges and packageForPath, over sources read out of each priced tree with git cat-file blob, which is the reading buildManifest does not perform because it reads each file from the working tree on disk. No fork unit may be called green from this rehearsal, because no fork head produced a mutation digest at all.
  • Hook state and hygiene: core.hooksPath is .husky/, and .husky/ holds post-checkout, post-commit, post-merge and pre-push only; there is no pre-commit entry there even though .husky carries a pre-commit script, so the replay's five commits ran no husky pre-commit leg and the manual leg set above is the only verification evidence. No --no-verify flag and no HUSKY override was used anywhere in the rehearsal, and no git add -A was used. The shared stash list still counts 19 entries; this lane created none and popped none. The rehearsal worktree is left checked out at the rehearsed 4e head with an empty porcelain, and it is not any unit's branch.
  • Mutation axis for a fork head stays unread: a fork head produces no digest comment and no head marker naming a run, so the absence of a digest is evidence about the cap and not about a leg failing to run. A fork unit is never reported green; it is reported as having no legs run upstream.

Ruleset figures, quoted as the dated read

  • The ruleset readings below are the dated rulesets REST read of 2026-11-10 of Zoo-Code-Org/Zoo-Code ruleset 15494382 (Protect Main), 1776 B, SHA-256 ebe59f3e0690ae5f0de3c0d520be4d4723483c66b7c323a3262b10a60eef16bf. They are a dated read and not a carried base: re-take them on the day of publication and re-quote or mark them stale.
  • From that read, on the pull_request rule: required_approving_review_count 1, dismiss_stale_reviews_on_push true, require_last_push_approval false, required_review_thread_resolution false, require_code_owner_review true, require_extra_approval_for_unattributed_changes true, dismissal_restriction disabled, merge methods merge, squash and rebase enabled, current_user_can_bypass never, merge queue configured SQUASH, ALLGREEN, 5 entries and 60 minutes. Six required contexts named by that read: check-translations, platform-unit-test (ubuntu-latest), platform-unit-test (windows-latest), compile, knip, e2e-mock.
  • Consequence stated once: a push to a pull dismisses an approval only when an approval exists to dismiss; nothing should be pushed to 2414 while it carries its one bot approval.

Killers arrive in the merged state

  • four rows in the 76ab52f digest are paid here: ClineProvider.ts:527 on viewLocalStateWriteVersions, both mutants at 564 on nextViewId, and the false branch at 2266. Fifteen survived rows are carried with their donor ranges and are not answered here (310 and 504 tied to pendingViewStateWrites and scheduledViewStateWrites first at donor spec 7221 and 7213 inside the it at 7194, carried by 4c; 493 on wroteUnderTemporaryViewStateId first at 6806 inside the test at 6780, carried by 4b; the eleven mutants at 1037 tied to 4b; the four _disposed rows first at 2796 inside the test at 2779, carried by 3a). The row at src/core/config/ProviderSettingsManager.ts:62 is priced by unit 2 in PR 2411.
  • Reading rule, stated with the areas rather than as an abstraction: the digest that lists these survivors is a reading taken with the killers for these areas absent, because the mutation leg prices a unit's changed executable lines and runs against the specs present at that unit's head. The killers land in the merged state in the declared order above rather than at any intermediate head, so a Survived row at 2414's head is a claim about the state at that head and not a verdict about this unit.
  • Clearing event, unchanged: the merge of 2414, then each unit re-based onto main and re-opened upstream on its own fork head. Only then can these kills appear as Killed rows in a digest comment.

Fold match

  • Fold artifact: local ref refs/pr/2226 at bc724b8, subject "fix(webview): keep memory and storage agreeing when a re-key recovery write fails", commit date Thu Nov 5 17:35:30 2026 +0800. It is an ancestor of 2411 only; merge-base(fold, u3a..u4e) is e943530, and every fork unit is main-based on main tip 18861b2. All fold-to-unit comparisons below are fold region against unit head region, and unit head region against its own merge base for widths.
  • Owed label kinds: 39 owed label kinds remain after this unit (54 at 2411 and 2414, 39 here). Fold tail ranges as recorded: 5723-7342 for 3b, 6124-7342 for 4a, 6245-7340 for 4b, 6245-6246 and 6966-7342 for 4c, none from 4d on.
  • Reviewer-facing need for this family: the fold names the region 1666-1667 and the unit region is 1643-1672 (class: fold region against unit head region). The two lines the fold carries there are a comment and this.pendingViewStateClaims.clear().
  • Content divergence, measured by occurrence count rather than line presence: the fold's provider blob carries pendingViewStateClaims.clear() at two occurrences, 1050 and 1667, while every head of this chain from 3a through 4e carries it once, at 1032 in 3a, 1040 at 76ab52f and 1048 from 3b on. That one-against-two reading is the only content divergence in the provider file, and it is repaired at unit 3b, where the owed patch below is staged; every later unit inherits it through the chain rather than carrying its own copy.
  • Where the owed patch stands after the rehearsal, measured rather than reasoned: at the rehearsed 4e head the provider file against the fold artifact drops from 19 hunks to 18 on the unified=0 basis, and the dispose-region hunk that used to read @@ -1666,2 +1664,0 @@ and deleted the fold's two lines is gone, so this content divergence is resolved by the patch. The patch was not inert against this chain's own spec as that spec stood before the amendment: the assertion at spec line 6956 quoted in the verification section failed at the rehearsed 4e head in two consecutive runs and at no earlier head, and the fold's spec carries no test of that name, so the fold's behaviour and the chain's asserted behaviour disagreed about whether a disposed provider keeps a queued claim. The Lead ruled in round 44 that fidelity to the source of record governs and that the assertion changes at unit 4e, where the assertion lives, so the row now asserts the release that the clear produces and keeps both of its anti-delivery assertions: the suite at the amended head prints 402 passed of 402 at exit 0 where the unrepaired rehearsed head printed 1 failed and 401 passed of 402 at exit 1, and the resolution, with the old assertion quoted verbatim beside the new one and with the two named production perturbations that show the amended row discriminates, is the section Resolution of the unit 4e assertion conflict below. This unit's own spec carries no assertion about the claim map after dispose, which is why its leg passed 361 of 361; the assertion that disagrees with the clear arrives with unit 4e.
  • Ordering divergence, disclosed and not changed: the fold advances the generation counter first (viewStateGeneration++ at fold 1652) and then sets the disposed flag (_disposed = true at fold 1653, adjacent to it), while every head of this chain sets the flag first (_disposed = true at unit 1648) and advances the counter second (1652). The interval between them, unit lines 1649 to 1651, holds comments only: no statement, no read, no await, and no arming call, and dispose's first await is further down the method. Neither field is an accessor: _disposed is declared at 343 and viewStateGeneration at 524 with no getter or setter, and no read of either sits inside the interval. The orderings are therefore equivalent within dispose; the divergence is reported as ordering, no code is changed for it and no test is written for it.
  • Assembly artifacts, listed so they are not mistaken for owed content: a braced splice guard in the chain against a one-line guard in the fold, a three-line detach comment whose wording differs, two blank lines at different positions, two relocated blocks (type PersistedViewState and the register-view-id doc), and main-line drift that is present at main tip and therefore not owed.

Coordinates that move because of the owed patch

  • How the mapping was measured, not predicted: for each coordinate published in a body of this chain, the text standing at that line in the published provider blob was located again in the provider blob of the rehearsed head that body will be published against, and the number below is where that text actually lands. The insertion sits after line 1664 and before the throttled cancel: line 1665 is the comment and line 1666 the statement in the rehearsed blobs of 3b, 4a, 4b, 4c, 4d and 4e alike, where the fold carries the same pair at 1666 and 1667. Coordinates strictly above 1664 move by two, a range that straddles the insertion keeps its start and extends its end, and coordinates at or below 1664 do not move. The spec blob at every rehearsed head is byte-identical to the published spec blob of the same unit, so no spec coordinate, no digest coordinate and no coordinate naming another blob moves anywhere in these bodies.
  • This body publishes no provider coordinate above 1664, so no line number in it moves. The figures that move are widths and gate prices, and each was read off the rehearsed head: own price 162 to 163 changed executable lines with selectors 65 to 66, own delta 345 to 347 provider additions and 747 to 749 unit additions, chain additions 3193 to 3195 with ClineProvider.ts 932 to 934, and the chain gate figure 522 to 523. The rehearsed measurement agrees with the two-line arithmetic, and it was obtained independently of it.
  • Gate figures, each naming its base class: against this unit's own merge base the price is the one printed in the Gate axis 1 section above, and against main tip 18861b2 the chain prints types 8 changed executable lines in 1 file with 2 selectors and extension 523 in 6 files with 149 selectors against the 500-line cap, so the abort sentence reads exactly: Error: extension has 523 changed executable lines (limit 500). Split the PR or obtain a maintainer-reviewed narrow exclusion. The provider file's own changed executable lines on that base go 477 to 478, and of the 49 differing numbers only 1666 is a new line; the other 48 are pre-existing lines renumbered by the insertion.

Rehearsal of the rebase (local rehearsal, no branch moved, no REST call)

  • Why it was run: three claims about the rebase were resting on reasoning rather than measurement, that the patch is inherited rather than duplicated downstream, that the two added lines are inert against the suite, and that the replay preserves content. A rehearsal under scratch refs settles all three, and it also produced a coordinate table that does not depend on arithmetic.
  • The six rehearsed heads, each pinned under a scratch ref, with its tree and the two blobs that matter: 3b 45da402, tree 695b7e45372ef1c50628554f900dc42caadaa0a8, provider blob ec5a6056ba5c0617125761206747fab24ea05134, spec blob f042726dfbdb95e2db748ac057e3a50265ef4f54; 4a 1a65899, tree ee0df21e2b90f64e2cb6efbf7d2f1e502ad57ce1, provider 21d8672e063774401a6040ced7485162c5f4fc82, spec cd153dda1b93dbfad579d718ecaeb1e329c5b54e; 4b d95b643, tree 07be2516a556c5efda202638587c4e09322c68f7, provider 21d8672e063774401a6040ced7485162c5f4fc82, spec 7ede4ac2c6baf2a5d944f53789375b9da5cb31b1; 4c 20e93af, tree 1c1f3190d9c79efbf53643438989ab6586f8b7fb, provider 21d8672e063774401a6040ced7485162c5f4fc82, spec 87fb9bf91492f99074fd461f5e074e266460253d; 4d b76d980, tree 8f7a8b86254bfebf3be7d1940c7e60acf133e8ef, provider 21d8672e063774401a6040ced7485162c5f4fc82, spec 7ada8807cb30d42e9d92683c019fa59a3b1ca3df; 4e 4350bbd591ddafc76e6f047a6c2bbe39ad0ff85a, tree e707bc98b558457a1eb38cd2fc5b94e3b9a174b7, provider 21d8672e063774401a6040ced7485162c5f4fc82, spec d6d1dc08e52c8624db06d101e60ff11a348a15d1. Each is the published unit's own commit cherry-picked with -x onto the rehearsed head below it, with identity f0-1528 f0-1528@local and a fixed author and committer date of 2026-11-10T23:1N:00+00:00 so the ids are reproducible. All five replayed without a conflict, and the only auto-merge was unit 4a's provider hunk.
  • Idempotence against the staged artifact: the rehearsed 4e tree e707bc98b558457a1eb38cd2fc5b94e3b9a174b7 is the same tree as the staged patched 4e commit f5873b91bd3a57b2b90786f2a97e30ab6085e84d, so the replay reproduces what was staged instead of inventing a third shape.
  • Content preservation: at every unit the spec blob of the rehearsed head is byte-identical to the spec blob published at the fork head, with the ids listed above. The only file the replay touches in any unit is src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts, at every unit by the single hunk @@ -1662,6 +1662,8 @@ with 2 additions and 0 deletions, so the only provider-blob change in the whole replay is the patched one: 850acb3a4d72201f930d9dbc5af5522dda18b379 to ec5a6056ba5c0617125761206747fab24ea05134 at unit 3b and 606642696490e16fcb4202d04946e1349d39b388 to 21d8672e063774401a6040ced7485162c5f4fc82 from unit 4a onward, unchanged across 4b, 4c, 4d and 4e.
  • Where it was done, stated because checkouts of this tree are expensive: one worktree, C:\work\Zoo-Code-fork\wt-f0-1528-rehearse, materialised once from the staged 3b commit and then walked commit by commit inside itself, so the LFS objects were smudged once rather than five times; it is not any unit's branch, no unit branch was moved, and the shared stash count stayed 19.

Resolution of the unit 4e assertion conflict (ruled in round 44)

  • The ruling, restated so the body carries its own justification: fidelity to the source of record wins, so the committed assertion changes at the unit that carries it. The fold, which is the source of record for this split, clears the claim map at dispose; the chain's row was written against the behaviour that predates the clear. Dropping the clear to keep the assertion would have bought the smaller diff at the cost of the divergence the patch was commissioned to remove.
  • The row before the amendment, quoted verbatim, title included, at spec lines 6944 and 6956 of the published and rehearsed 4e spec blob d6d1dc08e52c8624db06d101e60ff11a348a15d1: test("holds a disposed provider's queued claim without attempting delivery", async () => { ... expect(provider["pendingViewStateClaims"].get("view-a")).toBe("claim-a"). The row after the amendment, same two line numbers, at the amended spec blob f47e3b9ae1a8b863ae82bab831b0ac0af83e16e6: test("releases a disposed provider's queued claim without attempting delivery", async () => { ... expect(provider["pendingViewStateClaims"].get("view-a")).toBeUndefined(). The two expect assertions that guard against delivery, expect(attemptSpy).not.toHaveBeenCalled() and expect(postMessageSpy).not.toHaveBeenCalled(), are untouched, which is the point of amending the assertion rather than deleting the row.
  • Disclosure about the row's name: the title word changed from holds to releases, because the old title states the behaviour the ruling rejected and a row whose name contradicts its assertion is a fresh defect. The change is one word, it moves no line number, and it does not change the count of chain-only test titles, since both the old and the new title exist only in this chain and not in the fold; the fold's spec contains 0 occurrences of either phrase (instrument: JavaScript RegExp over the fold spec blob text read by git cat-file blob; unit: occurrences; cap none). At the pre-amendment rehearsed 4e spec the phrase holds a disposed provider occurs 1 time and releases a disposed provider 0 times; at the amended 4e spec they are 0 and 1 (same instrument, same unit, no cap). If the ruling intended the title string to stay verbatim, the revert is a one word edit at 4e that changes no count, no coordinate and no figure, and this lane will run it on request.
  • Condition one, the old assertion quoted beside the new: satisfied above in this body and in the ledger, with the title quoted alongside it so that a reader who sees only the new line can still tell a correction from a softening.
  • Condition two, discriminating power proved rather than assumed, all four cells run at the same head with the interpreter C:\Program Files\nodejs\node.exe, node v25.9.0, and vitest 4.1.12 invoked as src/node_modules/vitest/vitest.mjs run core/webview/tests/ClineProvider.spec.ts from the src directory of C:\work\Zoo-Code-fork\wt-f0-1528-rehearse. Cell A, the amended row against production as it stands at the amended head, where dispose clears the map: 1 test file passed, 402 passed of 402, exit 0. Cell B, the amended row against perturbation P1, a named variant of production at the same head in which dispose attempts delivery instead of releasing quietly, the dispose region line this.pendingViewStateClaims.clear() replaced by await this.deliverPendingViewStateClaims() and the comment line above it replaced by a line naming the perturbation, the change applied to the worktree disk as an uncommitted local patch and reverted afterwards, the patched file content sha256 c59e9599f51800356159c7806740254ea87d1e9158636d79a2a1fc1597cc40e4 over 252,707 bytes where the unrepaired-by-this-perturbation file is daeace41bda9c4077054f5f74babfd7c537aa8a90bb68def705339e16ee71530 over 252,694 bytes (unit: bytes, instrument: Buffer.length on the file text read from the worktree disk, cap none): 1 test file failed with 1 failed and 401 passed of 402, exit 1, the failing row being the amended one, reporting expected 'claim-a' to be undefined at spec line 6956. Cell C, the published row against the same perturbation P1: 402 passed of 402, exit 0, which is what makes cell B evidence: the published assertion passes in a world where dispose attempts delivery, so it was the retention claim that was blind, and the amended row fails there and passes at correct production. Cell D, the amended row against perturbation P2, in which the clear line is replaced by a placeholder statement so that dispose neither clears nor attempts delivery, the behaviour that predates the repair, file content sha256 3cfabbb54618db3d9eb5195bb20d273db3fa3164ca80fd501dc7b19b434d25c4 over 252,669 bytes: 1 test file failed with 1 failed and 401 passed of 402, exit 1 at the same row. The amended row therefore fails in both named worlds and passes in the correct one, so it is not a guard row and its published contribution is not 0 killers; it requires release without delivery, which is the behaviour the fold carries.
  • Condition three, completeness. Every occurrence of the field pendingViewStateClaims in the spec blobs of the chain was inventoried with the four-part presence test, counts at both the published and the rehearsed head, line identifiers, whether the occurrence sits inside the range the unit adds, and whether it is a test header, a seed or an assertion, and each assertion was further classified by whether a dispose call appears earlier in its own test body. The counts, with the instrument named as a JavaScript RegExp and line scan over blob text and no cap: 3b spec 0 occurrences, 4a spec 0 occurrences, 4b spec 8, 4c spec 8, 4d spec 8, 4e spec 17 occurrences of which 12 are assertions and 5 are seed calls. Of the 12 assertions at 4e, exactly one sits after a dispose call in its own test body, the row at 6956 whose dispose call is at 6949; the two sibling rows at 6972 and 6990 assert retention before their dispose calls and are therefore unaffected, and the eleven others never call dispose before asserting. The inventories are recorded in .tmp-cr-audit/.tmp-t339-claims-occurrences.json, 14,219 bytes, sha256 bb85c60a74514088cf72efb2a4bc747b2ecfbbe2d43725eac4ec3eed1666750c, and .tmp-cr-audit/.tmp-t339b-claim-assert-dispose.json, 7,226 bytes, sha256 c44fae773d082a44c7866987ae7758ef67e8d683352f1c5aff2c4fb4eabc5ef8. So the stale assertion class is one row, not a family, and the amendment covers it; the run agrees, since the suite failed at exactly that one row and at no other.
  • Condition four, the suite and the classifier re-run at the amended head. Suite: 1 test file passed, 402 passed of 402, exit 0, where the unrepaired rehearsed head printed 1 failed and 401 passed of 402 at exit 1 and the published fork head prints 402 passed of 402 at exit 0. The three EnvironmentTeardownError rows that appeared in the first failing run and not in the confirming run are flanking noise and are reported as noise; the assertion failure appeared in both runs. Classifier, blob pricing through the committed instrument scripts/stryker-diff.mjs blob 7dfe0006d2d5c7e4d2282f65f68b8ed5f16866bc with sources read by git cat-file blob from the head being priced, interpreter node v25.9.0: against its own rehearsed parent b76d980 (base class: the unit's own merge base, printed by git merge-base) the amended head prices packages [], an empty manifest, exit 0, because the unit delta touches only a spec file, which the instrument excludes; against upstream main tip 18861b2 (base class: main tip, printed by git merge-base for that pair) it prices types 8 changed executable lines in 1 file with 2 selectors and extension 523 changed executable lines in 6 files with 149 selectors against the instrument cap MAX_CHANGED_LINES 500, and the instrument's own thrown sentence is unchanged: Error: extension has 523 changed executable lines (limit 500). Split the PR or obtain a maintainer-reviewed narrow exclusion. The unrepaired published 4e head prices extension 522 with 148 selectors on the same base, so 523 and 149 belong to a tree carrying the claim clear and this amendment leaves both figures unmoved; every priced figure here names the tree it was priced on. The pricing pass is recorded in .tmp-cr-audit/.tmp-t342-amendment-pricing.json, 7,686 bytes, sha256 017a4619b7f9f9ae6a0e12b31bed92e68845052455fab63496fd4505c7dcb867.
  • Legs re-run at the amended head because its spec blob changed, each under C:\Program Files\nodejs\node.exe node v25.9.0: prettier 3.9.10 --check on the spec and the provider paths exit 0; cold tsc 5.9.3 --noEmit from the src directory with no .tsbuildinfo present exit 0 with 0 rows containing error TS; eslint 9.39.5 --prune-suppressions --max-warnings=0 on those two paths exit 0, with src/eslint-suppressions.json read at 30,910 bytes sha256 055a26991146ecea72251521394f0c57d366b4db2f126cdaadd34dc82cc0ce54 and rewritten by the prune to 33,294 bytes sha256 0615a5cfb68632d2098a22586ddb74e3e55e3dba43ba731897f372fac534510a, the two maps deep-equal over 265 flattened rows each with 0 differing rows, the spec entry staying core/webview/tests/ClineProvider.spec.ts at 195 suppressed no-explicit-any counts, and the file then restored byte-identical and verified by digest; eslint 9.39.5 --max-warnings=0 without the prune flag exit 0. Byte counts in this bullet are Buffer.length on the file text read from disk, row counts are JSON walks, and none is capped.
  • The artifact that carries the amendment: commit c807c99, tree 92a672a7787c92ba2bde24c2ec1cab0c361a6558, parent b76d980 (the rehearsed 4d scratch head), spec blob f47e3b9ae1a8b863ae82bab831b0ac0af83e16e6, provider blob 21d8672e063774401a6040ced7485162c5f4fc82 unchanged from the rehearsed 4e tree, pinned as refs/heads/f0-1528-rehearsed-4e-amended with the rehearsal identity and a commit date of Tue Nov 10 22:55:25 2026 +0000. The tree differs from the rehearsed 4e tree e707bc98b558457a1eb38cd2fc5b94e3b9a174b7 in exactly one path, the spec file. The rehearsal worktree C:\work\Zoo-Code-fork\wt-f0-1528-rehearse now sits detached at c807c99 with empty porcelain, and the six scratch refs of the round 41 rehearsal still exist unchanged.
  • What this unit carries: nothing. The amendment lands at unit 4e, which is downstream of this unit, so this unit's own spec blob is unchanged by it and stays f042726dfbdb95e2db748ac057e3a50265ef4f54 at the fork head and at the rehearsed head alike, and this unit's own delta, gate price and suite row are unmoved by the amendment.
  • What the amendment does not touch, stated so a reader does not have to infer it: the provider file is unchanged, so the fold match measured on that file is unaffected and the hunk counts and the vanished dispose-region hunk recorded in the Fold match section above stand unchanged; the fold-vs-chain test-title inventory keeps its count of 18 chain-only titles, though one member of that set is now named releases a disposed provider's queued claim without attempting delivery rather than holds a disposed provider's queued claim without attempting delivery; the twelve-row clearing-event table queued for the tracking comment reads 6956 as the amended assertion; and the mutation leg is still not run at any rehearsed or amended head, for the reason given in the verification section, so the killer rows quoted elsewhere in this body are figures measured at the published heads and this lane states no mutation figure for the amended head rather than assuming one. No fork unit is reported green.

Publication stamps to carry in the body

  • The body write for this pull is recorded out of band in .tmp-cr-audit/.tmp-t361-body-writes.json, which carries the PATCH status, the response date, the read-back created_at and updated_at, the body digest taken from the read-back text and the digest of that record itself; a body cannot contain the digest of the write that produces it, and the figures are printed there and in the report to the Lead.
  • Check-runs read for the head 45da402 at 2026-11-11T00:31:51.416Z UTC by GET /repos/easonLiangWorldedtech/Zoo-Code/commits/45da4029d0738920c9631790fda70d0d911191b5/check-runs on the fork, http 200: total_count 0, no rows. This is a statement about the check surface at that head on the fork and not a claim that any verification leg ran, because a fork head issues no directive run.

Update from the lane, recorded 2026-11-11T02:2xZ UTC, as a pull-level statement rather than a reply to any thread. This pull now sits at 8dc5818, moved from 45da402 by a push whose lease was pinned to the same run's read of refs/heads/vps2/2226-u3b-preview at that earlier value and which is proved by the post-push read-back reading the new head equal to the intended head rather than by its exit code. The move is one commit carrying only a test file, src/core/webview/tests/ClineProvider.view-state-claim-guard.spec.ts, 8044 bytes and 272 lines, blob 9c2a7365806a, six tests over the seven mutated rows in ClineProvider.ts lines 1157, 1179, 1186, 1191, 1198, 1200 and 1206, prettier and eslint with prune-suppressions and max-warnings 0 clean on it, the package type-check clean, and vitest on that file reporting 6 passed of 6. The width counter was re-run on trees after the commit rather than inherited: on the parent axis from 735dc22 correcting a transcription error, the published string was 39 characters because a digit was dropped rather than reordered and therefore fails the mutation instrument own rule that a commit sha must be a full 40 character value, so the parent axis base is this 40 character object to this head it reads extension 163 changed executable lines, identical to the figure measured before the commit, so the new spec moved no axis, and over the merge base 18861b2 this 3b tree alone reads extension 515 changed executable lines, which is above the 500 limit by 15 lines on the axis CI prices and is a different quantity from the 523 priced over the same base at the 4e chain head c807c99, that figure covering the whole chain rather than this unit, so nothing here should be read as a unit sitting under the cap. The pre-push hook was measured as git runs it in the worktree under the pre-push revision this branch itself carries, 1385 bytes sha256 719b2b28d50f, not the main checkout's 1427 bytes sha256 3d9be95e3ad5, with core.hooksPath .husky/_ so the generated shim chains to the tracked hook, and with one ref line on stdin naming this branch it exits 0 running check-types in 13 packages. Finally, and this is the fact a maintainer needs before reading anything above as a pipeline result: a read of the check-run set on this repository at the new head returns total_count 0 with an empty set, so a push to this fork produces no check runs at all, the six required contexts exist only on the upstream side, and this pull carries no CI of its own; what it offers is its tree plus the local measurements named here, and the mutation stage that prices these rows is advisory in the ruleset, which makes the width and mutant questions a maintainer conversation rather than a merge block.

Carries the ClineProvider view-state state machine and the spec ranges this plan assigns to 3b, replayed from fb6d054958862e448b7a0afd836f5b0040a87e64 onto 76ab52f, plus the six lines of ViewStateRegistrationResult and its doc comment that unit 3a gave to 3b by ruling.

The orphan doc note about the fields a view owns is carried here rather than left behind: 735dc22 deleted it from unit 3a because no declaration in that tree carried the name, and this unit adds the declaration, so the note sits above it as it does at line 292 of the donor provider blob.
Stryker still reports a surviving ConditionalExpression at src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts line 1198 with replacement true, which makes any live provider count as the claimant regardless of which view state id it holds. Every earlier case used a second instance holding the same id, so none of them separated that behaviour from a guard that actually compares ids. This case gives the other instance a different id and requires a free id to adopt, which is exactly what the flipped comparison breaks. A companion case that re-affirmed an id the provider already held was tried and dropped: that path is a no-op reporting adopted false, so it cannot reach this mutant. No suppression and no Stryker disable were added.
Stryker still reports survivors at src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts lines 1218 and 1220 and 1223. The 1218 row is a StringLiteral whose replacement is the empty string, so the assertion is on the delivery value the caller reads rather than on the adopted flag alone. The 1220 and 1223 rows are the entry test and the stored-claim test, both of which survive in the direction that skips the re-bind, leaving a pre-claim entry unbound under a key this view now owns; that case seeds an entry with no claim token and asserts the entry itself gains a string token, reading the store rather than the result. A third case for a bound entry was tried and dropped: registering an id whose entry already carries a stored claim token reports adopted false when no claim is presented, so the premise was wrong about the product and no assertion was bent to fit. No suppression and no Stryker disable were added.
Stryker reports a ConditionalExpression at src/core/webview/ClineProvider.ts line 1230 whose replacement false adopts a key a concurrent registration has just bound, and uncovered StringLiterals at lines 1235 and 1248 carrying the two refusal reasons. The concurrent case reads the entry once without a claim token, which sends the re-bind off, and once with a token, which is what a competing registration leaves behind, and requires the refusal to reach the caller together with the reason the code states at line 1235. The foreign claim case seeds an entry holding a token this launch did not present and asserts the stated reason at line 1248 rather than the adoption flag alone, because replacing the reason with an empty template keeps the refusal and drops the explanation. A first attempt at this commit edited the spec by string surgery and left it unparseable, prettier exit 2 with no commit made, so the file was restored from the HEAD blob and the two cases appended whole. No suppression and no Stryker disable were added.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant