diff --git a/CounterStrikeProgression.Site/Views/CompareViewBuilder.cs b/CounterStrikeProgression.Site/Views/CompareViewBuilder.cs
index b816944..b107ea8 100644
--- a/CounterStrikeProgression.Site/Views/CompareViewBuilder.cs
+++ b/CounterStrikeProgression.Site/Views/CompareViewBuilder.cs
@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ namespace ktsu.CounterStrikeProgression.Site.Views;
 using ktsu.CounterStrikeProgression.Core.Challenges;
 using ktsu.CounterStrikeProgression.Core.Progression;
 using ktsu.CounterStrikeProgression.Core.SkillShots;
+using ktsu.CounterStrikeProgression.Core.Weapons;
 
 /// <summary>One player's totals on the compare page.</summary>
 /// <param name="SteamId">The 64-bit Steam ID as a decimal string.</param>
@@ -126,8 +127,12 @@ private static CompareSide Side(PlayerProgress progress, PlayerView view, Player
 	{
 		long kills = progress.Weapons.Values.Sum(w => w.Kills);
 		long headshots = progress.Weapons.Values.Sum(w => w.Headshots);
-		long hits = progress.Weapons.Values.Sum(w => w.Hits);
-		long shots = progress.Weapons.Values.Sum(w => w.Shots);
+
+		// Only guns record shots, so knife and Zeus hits would raise accuracy with nothing to divide
+		// them by. Count hits and shots over guns alone, as LifeTracker does for a life's accuracy.
+		List<WeaponProgress> guns = [.. progress.Weapons.Where(w => WeaponCatalog.Find(w.Key)?.IsGun == true).Select(w => w.Value)];
+		long hits = guns.Sum(w => w.Hits);
+		long shots = guns.Sum(w => w.Shots);
 		return new(
 			view.SteamId,
 			view.Name,
diff --git a/CounterStrikeProgression.Test/CompareTests.cs b/CounterStrikeProgression.Test/CompareTests.cs
index ac8ffae..c74970a 100644
--- a/CounterStrikeProgression.Test/CompareTests.cs
+++ b/CounterStrikeProgression.Test/CompareTests.cs
@@ -77,6 +77,23 @@ public void Build_TotalsEachPlayerAcrossWeapons()
 		Assert.AreEqual(75, view.B.Accuracy);
 	}
 
+	[TestMethod]
+	public void Build_AccuracyCountsOnlyGunsBecauseKnifeAndZeusRecordNoShots()
+	{
+		PlayerProgress player = Shooter();
+		WeaponProgress knife = player.Weapon(TestHelpers.Weapon("knife").Key);
+		knife.Kills = 4;
+		knife.Hits = 30;
+		WeaponProgress taser = player.Weapon(TestHelpers.Weapon("taser").Key);
+		taser.Kills = 1;
+		taser.Hits = 1;
+
+		CompareView view = CompareViewBuilder.Build(player, true, NoSeason, Sniper(), false, NoSeason, new ProgressionSettings());
+
+		Assert.AreEqual(50, view.A.Accuracy, "Knife and Zeus hits, which never record a shot, raised the gun accuracy.");
+		Assert.AreEqual(15, view.A.Kills, "Knife and Zeus kills still count toward the kill total.");
+	}
+
 	[TestMethod]
 	public void Build_ListsEveryWeaponEitherPlayerUsed()
 	{