diff --git a/src/toad/wire_history.py b/src/toad/wire_history.py
index 93e9d610c..7b65b2846 100644
--- a/src/toad/wire_history.py
+++ b/src/toad/wire_history.py
@@ -323,8 +323,8 @@ def read(self, request: PageRequest[WireCut], through: AfterSequence) -> Prepare
         page = request.end.wire_page(self, request.cursor, through)
         shown = MessageShown(style=self.style)
         fragments = tuple(
-            WireFragment.of(message, shown=shown, evidence=page.evidence_for(message), reader=self.me)
-            for message in page.messages
+            WireFragment.of(message, shown=shown, evidence=evidence, reader=self.me)
+            for message, evidence in page.message_evidence()
         )
         wire = WirePage(
             page.messages,